Teams seem to think they might. The fact that both have roster bonuses probably backs them into a corner.
Yeah, I don't know what their plan was in signing both.
They'd have a shot at a Superbowl somewhere in the small window of early years where Herbert's new deal isn't sucking away too much of the cap and in anticipation of a major cap increase?
Well looking at it, that window was 2023, a year Herbert and Bosa unfortunately spent a lot of on IR.
Bosa: $15,776,666
Mack: $16,632,500
Herbert: $8,458,176
Because in 2024 you have
29 year old Bosa: $36,611,666
33 year old Mack: $38,517,500
32 year old Keenan Allen $34,717,500
30 year old Mike Williams $32,460,000
Herbert: $19,345,675
... and no guarantees of health.
IMO you pocket 8 million in cap savings by cutting Mack, stick with Bosa's deal in 2024 and cut him in 2025 (when Herbert's cap number hits $37,345,675) while trying to develop new pass rushers and WRs .