Two COMPLETELY different eras. You should be ashamed to even hint that those two QBs are even in the same stratosphere.
Why ridicule Hurts? He is just starting his career so why not wait until he has a chance to see how things turn out. Aikman has a pretty shakey start also. You are comparing without any basis for knowing how things will turn out. Shame on you as well.
Maybe not. I don’t see why however why it is fair to write off someone before they ever started. Fair is fair.
Hurts has played enough to see what he is. An inaccurate passer that runs well. That has a pretty damn good online in front of him.
Hurts has never started?
Hurts QBRating is is 84.7.
Might want to check again...
www.espn.com
His career has barley started. His career is just getting underway. Aikman had several years to build his career and establish what you are using to compare with Hurts. It not a fair comparison to write him off at this point. Unless you are willing to look at Aikman and only use the first year and half as his total production. The thing is everyone’s is basing Hurts abilities on assessments of a few games. Give the kid a chance to play out and then make an assessment.
That is his rating but Shoop is correct with his QBR rating. It was even worse the year before.
HurtsMight want to check again...
Jalen Hurts - Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback - ESPN
View the profile of Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback Jalen Hurts on ESPN. Get the latest news, live stats and game highlights.
| Year | Team | CMP% | YDS | TD | INT | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | Eagles | 61.3 | 3,144 | 16 | 9 | 87.2 |
| 2020 | Eagles | 52.0 | 1,061 | 6 | 4 | 77.6 |
| Career | 59.0 | 4,205 | 22 | 13 | 84.7 |
Yeah based on 4 games as a rookie.
yeah Aikmams QBR hisrookie year was 55.7 after 11 games.
Your insistence on comparing Hurts to Aikman is strange. Two completely different QBs, in two completely different eras. Aikman early on took a beating behind an awful oline, and had a young Irvin with nobody else, yet you could still see he had something. Hurts has a very good line, and pretty good skill position players helping him out. And you can still see he has awful mechanics, to go along with awful accuracy. And a tendency to pull it down and run before he should.
Hurts didnt have to go through what Aikman did either. Much better team than Aikmans team so of course his QBR was going to be bad.
I’m not going to die on anyones hill. I’m comparing Hurts early career with Aikman and there’s not a hell of of lot of difference. I’m willing to see how things turn out with a fair and objective assessment when a career is established rather than parrot what someone is saying about it.
Apparently, you do not know the difference between QBR and passer rating. Shoop was correct in stating his QBR was 48.5 last year.
Again.... TWO COMPLETELY DIFFERENT ERAS. Why is this so hard for you to grasp?
I saw Aikman early career up close and personal and he struggled his first couple years. Hurts also struggled but he hasn’t had an opportunity to play out what ever his legacy may be. When he does then I will assess him as a viable QB.
