- Props to the time spent, but doesn’t uncover anything new. Prescott isn’t HOFer Mahomes, Rodgers, Peyton, Brees. No shit. Prescott performs worse vs better defenses. Find me a non-HOFer that doesn’t.
- At this point, most interesting thing you can research is why we haven’t had that one year. Even goes back to Romo. Lots of good/lesser QBs have had that one year for at least a CC game — Carson Palmer, Goff (twice), Nick Foles (allegedly, Geng), Keenum, Matt Ryan, Cam Newton, Eli Manning, Rex Grossman, Hasselbeck, Stafford, Garoppolo, Hurts. That’s 13 of the last 19 NFCCs, meaning 35% of NFCC QBs had that one year. How is it that Romo and Prescott are seemingly the only two Pro Bowlers that haven’t and both are Cowboys?
- Thinking out loud, probably the most relevant study for Prescott is showing QB %-to-cap with NFCC appearances or performance. Is Prescott the only one?
Focusing on the 'WTF not even one year it comes together'...
Since the 2006 season:
A. 23 QBs have multiple Pro Bowls (excluding replacement invites). Only six QBs haven't reached the CC - Romo, Prescott, Kirk Cousins, Tagovailoa, Deshaun Watson, Kyler Murray.
B. Of 13 QBs with 3+ Pro Bowl non-replacement invites, only Prescott and Romo haven't reached CC.
C. 19 QBs with only one Pro Bowl non-replacement invite, essentially half have reached a CC/SB. Nine QBs.
-----
List of QBs from Above
A. Josh Allen, Kirk Cousins, Tagovailoa, Matt Stafford, Cam Newton, Eli Manning, Deshaun Watson, Carson Palmer, Brock Purdy, Kyler Murray plus B (below)
B. Brady, Rodgers, Peyton, Brees, Rivers, Mahomes, Roethlisberger, Russell Wilson, Lamar Jackson, Prescott, Matt Ryan, Romo, Favre
C. Joe Burrow (SB), Ryan Tannehill (CC), Kurt Warner (SB), Jay Cutler (CC), Jalen Hurts (SB), Andrew Luck (CC), Matt Hasselbeck (SB), Michael Vick (CC), Goff (SB), Carson Wentz, Matt Schaub, Derek Anderson, Vince Young, Jeff Garcia, RG III, Derek Carr, Justin Herbert, Marc Bulger, Geno Smith