Jimmy Johnson played hot-hand Beuerlein over franchise QB Aikman
Posted by Michael David Smith on December 3, 2015, 7:31 AM EST
Colts coach Chuck Pagano says it’s “ridiculous” to think he could play Matt Hasselbeck over a healthy Andrew Luck. But while it might be ridiculous, a move like that wouldn’t be unprecedented.
In fact, a Super Bowl-winning coach once sat his future Hall of Famer franchise quarterback on the bench and chose instead to start a journeyman who happened to be playing well at the time.
The coach was Jimmy Johnson, the future Hall of Famer was Troy Aikman, and the journeyman backup was Steve Beuerlein. With the Cowboys at 6-5 and fighting for a playoff spot in 1991, Aikman was knocked out of a game and replaced by Beuerlein, who led the Cowboys to a victory to improve them to 7-5. Beuerlein then started the final four games of the season, the Cowboys won all four and finished 11-5.
By the time the playoffs rolled around, Aikman was fully healthy, and Johnson had a choice to make: Go back to his former No. 1 draft pick and future franchise quarterback? Or stick with the backup who had gone 4-0 as a starter? Johnson chose to stay with Beuerlein for the Cowboys’ wild-card game, a win over the Bears.
Yes, although not many people talk about it when discussing the Cowboys’ dynasty of the 1990s, their first playoff win of the decade came with Beuerlein, not Aikman, under center.
The next week Johnson again started Beuerlein, but this time it didn’t go as well: The Cowboys were blown out by the Lions, and Johnson pulled Beuerlein during the game for Aikman. The following season Aikman was the starter from Day One, and the Cowboys won the first of their three Super Bowls with Aikman at the helm.
No one doubted in 1991 that Aikman was the future of the Cowboys, just as no one doubts now that Luck is the future of the Colts. But Johnson felt like he had to stick with the quarterback who had guided his team to a 4-0 record. Pagano doesn’t see it that way.
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/12/03/jimmy-johnson-played-hot-hand-beuerlein-over-franchise-qb-aikman/
-------------------------------------------------------
Ouch. PFT with the timely smackdown