MLB Chatter Thread

Tony D said:
Good little player? Yes.
All time great? No.
3000 hits? WGAS.
Click to expand...

Fifth all time in doubles, first all-time by a right-hander. 400+ steals. 7 time all-star.

"Good little player." :lol

Seriously, GFY.
 
Not to mention no whiff of any substantial PED claims for a player in the PED era.

Seriously, I am pissed. I may go challenge Murray Chass to a fistfight.
 
Kbrown said:
Not to mention no whiff of any substantial PED claims for a player in the PED era.

Seriously, I am pissed. I may go challenge Murray Chass to a fistfight.
Click to expand...

You have at least one writer that agrees with you.

 
Kbrown said:
Fifth all time in doubles, first all-time by a right-hander. 400+ steals. 7 time all-star.

"Good little player." :lol

Seriously, GFY.
Click to expand...

Listen, the HOF has been watered down so he'll get in. He's borderline. He compiled stats and I don't give a shit about compilers.

Go through every one of his season and count how many are HOF seasons? I could be wrong.
 
Ah, I should have known it was the "stat compiler" nonsense that's been debated here before. As if longevity is a black mark. As if guys who stick around a little past their prime are racking up cheap STEALS AND DOUBLES.

Whatever.
 
People must get a Jack Morris HOF bonus in their check the way they carry on about this great injustice.
 
As much as I like tradition and history and all that, it will be good for baseball when some of these fogies who imagine themselves as running around with press passes in bands of their fedoras decide to retire their votes.

I realize not many retire their votes voluntarily, but I'm not REALLY going to root for someone's death.
 
Kbrown said:
Ah, I should have known it was the "stat compiler" nonsense that's been debated here before. As if longevity is a black mark. As if guys who stick around a little past their prime are racking up cheap STEALS AND DOUBLES.

Whatever.
Click to expand...

Just asking the question. If he retired 5 years earlier way short of 3000 hits does he get in? If the answer is yes then I can buy it.

I don't like these 3000 hits or 300 wins guys that just got in because they hit that number. Now it'll be a long time before another 300 game winner.
 
Bob Roberts said:
People must get a Jack Morris HOF bonus in their check the way they carry on about this great injustice.
Click to expand...

Pitcher A 270-153 ERA 3.68 3562 IP 2813 K 785 BB WHIP 1.192 ERA+ 123
Pitcher B 254-186 ERA 3.90 3824 IP 2478 K 1390 BB WHIP 1.296 ERA+ 105

Mussina is pitcher A, Morris B. Morris won some big games in the playoffs I'll give him that.
 
Tony D said:
Just asking the question. If he retired 5 years earlier way short of 3000 hits does he get in? If the answer is yes then I can buy it.

I don't like these 3000 hits or 300 wins guys that just got in because they hit that number. Now it'll be a long time before another 300 game winner.
Click to expand...

I can understand your point. However, even if 3000+ hits does push him over the top, it necessarily works in conjunction with his other stats, his gold gloves, his silver sluggers.

Or at least it should. Who knows what the baseball writers think about?
 
Kbrown said:
I can understand your point. However, even if 3000+ hits does push him over the top, it necessarily works in conjunction with his other stats, his gold gloves, his silver sluggers.

Or at least it should. Who knows what the baseball writers think about?
Click to expand...

You can definitely talk me into Biggio more than some guys that have gotten in recently.
 
I still don't think Biggio is an all-time great player, which is what the HOF is for.
 
‏@Ken_Rosenthal

Sources: #Rays to sign free-agent IF Jayson Nix to minor-league deal.

Final piece to the puzzle.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom