I would love to see a scenario where Arvelle Reese falls to 12 because I then sprint to the podium and turn his card in.
Absent that, I can't say I am in love with any of the edges that seem likely in that 12 range. I liked the bit of film I watched on TJ Parker, but he's more a back of the first type unless he shoots up boards post-season. David Bailey looks good too, but he'll also probably be gone.
The others look too short and squat to me. That isn't to say they can't be good players, but, when I think of dominant edge rushers I am conditioned to think more of the Charles Haley, DeMarcus Ware, Micah Parsons types, rather than the Reggie White and Bruce Smith types. Maybe it's just because that's what Dallas's elite rushers have always been in my lifetime, but I want a leaner, speedier guy who is big enough to hold up against the run, but, leans more towards a speed rusher and can dip around the edge with a lightning quick first step. Jason Taylor, Kevin Greene, guys who are fine as 4-3 rush ends, but have the speed and athleticism to also be 3-4 OLBs.
Bailey doesn't look like that, but looks lean enough that he could be a power rush LB perhaps in a 3-4. Bain, Mesidor, Faulk, they look to me more like classic 4-3 ends and in my mind they don't look like dominant edge rushers. Perhaps more of power rushers from the end spot, but, not speed guys. I don't think they can move to 3-4 OLB as easily. Faulk looks like maybe he's a 3-4 end, even, like Chris Canty. Good player, but not gonna help your pass rush.
So that being said, unless Reese or, maybe Bailey, falls to 12, I don't love the pass rush options there. And Reese falling is so unlikely as to not really be worth counting on.
I don't love the idea of a DB either, and especially not a CB, and especially not if Delane is gone. Downs would be interesting just because safety has been a shit show for us for a while now, but he's not the ballhawking type, he's more of a box safety IMO. Still, if he's more competent on the back end than Wilson and Hooker, which hopefully he would be, that's an improvement.
Is Sonny Styles the best player on the board, then, for a team moving to a hybrid 3-4? Is he an ILB for you then? He's only 235 though.
I think my tentative idea would be to move down from 20, to 24-28 and get Parker or Cashius Howell. Howell actually looks a lot like the prototype edge rusher that I think can play 4-3 speed rush end, or 3-4 OLB, and can transition back and forth seamlessly. Recoup a second or third, or maybe also some extra later picks too?
So then what would be the plan at 12? I dunno, I think maybe move down there as well.
So let's say you move down from 12 to like 17-21. Can you pick up a second for that move? For 18 or 19, you are getting probably too much value if it's a second. 20 is your own pick. 21, with Pittsburgh, a second is not quite enough. OK, so let's say 21.
12 for 21 and 53, and a 5th (159).
Then with 20, move down to 26, with Buffalo.
20 for 26 and 91, and a 2027 5th (they don't have one this year).
So now that's
21
26
53
91
112
150
159
177
Now you go
21 CJ Allen (ILB for your 3-4)
26 Cashius Howell (edge rusher 3-4)
53 Keionte Scott (CB help)
91 best defender or OL
That's a decent start to resurrecting the defense.