At this point if there's a high floor, low ceiling RT type like Blake Miller available when we pick next year, I'm just taking him, unless there's a no-brainer Lamb type prospect on the board. I don't even give a shit about how athletic they are or how quick their feet are if they're a project, sign me up for some big asshole 5th year senior with 40 starts who can just stay in front of a guy.
You basically can't find OT's anywhere except the top 2 rounds, and you know for damn sure this group isn't going to be able to, so fuck it.
12 starting NFL OT’s were day three picks or UDFA’s and of this small list, Dallas has Terence Steele starting, Nate Thomas showing flashes and competing, and traded Asim Richards to the Saints where he is their swing OT.
So objectively we’re not total shit there, TBH, but we are behind Philly and GB by a lot— and that makes it feel even worse.
BTWl, these ‘late find’ starters aren’t that great—11/12 (91.7%) have neither a pro bowl or All Pro votes (ironically Mailata has one AP-2, but no pro bowls).
| Player | Entry | Pro Bowls | AP All-Pro |
| ----------------------- | ------------ | --------: | ---------------------: |
|
Jordan Mailata, PHI | 2018 R7 #233 |
0 |
1× 2nd Team (2024) |
| Dan Moore Jr. | 2021 R4 | 0 | 0 |
| Jalen Travis | 2025 R4 | 0 | 0 |
| Jaylon Moore | 2021 R5 | 0 | 0 |
| Jermaine Eluemunor | 2017 R5 | 0 | 0 |
| Braxton Jones | 2022 R5 | 0 | 0 |
| Warren McClendon Jr. | 2023 R5 | 0 | 0 |
| Colton McKivitz | 2020 R5 | 0 | 0 |
| Dylan Cook | UDFA | 0 | 0 |
| Terence Steele | UDFA | 0 | 0 |
| Elijah Wilkinson | UDFA | 0 | 0 |
| Alaric Jackson | UDFA | 0 | 0 |
When you focus on swing tackles, the numbers invert and 75% come from day three or UDFA.
| Team | Swing OT | Draft | 2025 PFF Overall | Snaps |
| ---- | ---------------------- | ----: | ---------------: | ----: |
| ARI |
Matt Pryor | R6 |
71.6 | 122 |
| BUF |
Tylan Grable | R6 |
70.0 | 72 |
| MIA |
Charlie Heck | R4 | — | — |
| NE |
Marcus Bryant | R7 |
49.0 | 18 |
| NYJ |
Max Mitchell | R4 |
69.6 | 73 |
| BAL |
Carson Vinson | R5 |
73.2 | 7 |
| CIN |
Cody Ford | R2 |
55.8 | 73 |
| CLE |
Dawand Jones | R4 |
32.8 | 143 |
| PIT |
Broderick Jones | R1 |
57.7 | 632 |
| HOU |
Blake Fisher | R2 |
67.6 | 337 |
| IND |
Blake Freeland | R4 |
N/S | 0 |
| JAX |
Chuma Edoga | R3 |
33.6 | 98 |
| TEN |
Austin Deculus | R6 |
36.5 | 516 |
| DEN |
Matt Peart | R3 |
29.9* | 64 |
| KC |
Esa Pole | UDFA | N/S | 0 |
| LV |
Charles Grant | R3 |
70.1 | 59 |
| LAC |
Trey Pipkins III | R3 |
47.2 | 606 |
| DAL |
Nate Thomas | R7 | 39.2 | 342 |
| NYG |
Marcus Mbow | R5 |
54.0 | 325 |
| PHI |
Fred Johnson | UDFA |
58.6 | 626 |
| WAS |
Brandon Coleman | R3 |
65.4 | 390 |
| CHI |
Ozzy Trapilo | R2 |
69.9 | 491 |
| DET |
Larry Borom | R5 |
60.7 | 664 |
| GB |
Darian Kinnard | R5 |
69.4 | 285 |
| MIN |
Ryan Van Demark | UDFA |
74.0 | 312 |
| ATL |
Wanya Morris | R3 |
57.1 | 66 |
| CAR |
Rasheed Walker | R7 |
64.6 | 986 |
| NO |
Asim Richards | R5 |
47.1 | 363 |
| TB |
Justin Skule | R6 |
65.7 | 578 |
| LAR |
David Quessenberry | R6 |
59.0 | 18 |
| SF |
Vederian Lowe | R6 |
61.4 | 317 |
| SEA |
Josh Jones | R3 |
74.3 | 258 |
Also, the jury is far from being out on Shelton. As a rookie, he could definitely use another offseason in an NFL weight room.
Some research over the last 7-8 years, based on swing tackles PFF grades and improvements over time
| Rank | Team | Development evidence | Best examples | Assessment |
| -----: | ------- | --------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | ------------- |
|
1 |
GB | Exceptional | Zach Tom R4, Rasheed Walker R7 |
Elite |
|
2 |
LAR | Exceptional | Alaric Jackson UDFA, Warren McClendon R5 |
Elite |
|
3 |
SF | Exceptional | Colton McKivitz R5, Justin Skule R6, Jaylon Moore R5 |
Elite |
|
4 |
PHI | Exceptional peak | Jordan Mailata R7, Jack Driscoll R4 |
Elite |
|
5 |
LAC | Strong | Jamaree Salyer R6, Foster Sarell UDFA |
Very good |
|
6 |
BUF | Strong recent pipeline | Ryan Van Demark UDFA*, Tylan Grable R6 |
Very good |
|
7 |
CHI | Multiple usable OTs | Braxton Jones R5, Larry Borom R5 |
Very good |
|
8 |
PIT | Strong starter conversion | Dan Moore Jr. R4 |
Good+ |
|
9 |
DAL | One major hit | Terence Steele UDFA |
Good+ |
|
10 |
MIN | Multiple useful reserves | Oli Udoh R6, Vederian Lowe R6 |
Good |
| 11 | LV | Useful late development | Thayer Munford R7 | Good |
| 12 | CLE | Multiple opportunities | Dawand Jones R4, James Hudson R4 | Good |
| 13 | HOU | Produces usable depth | Charlie Heck R4, Austin Deculus R6 | Above avg |
| 14 | SEA | Repeated usable depth | Stone Forsythe R6, Michael Jerrell R6 | Above avg |
| 15 | BAL | Some developmental success | Daniel Faalele R4 | Above avg |
| 16 | NYJ | Multiple playable reserves | Max Mitchell R4, Carter Warren R4 | Average+ |
| 17 | DEN | Some UDFA development | Quinn Bailey UDFA | Average |
| 18 | NE | Some late-round depth | Justin Herron R6 | Average |
| 19 | KC | Mixed | Darian Kinnard R5, Prince Tega Wanogho | Average |
| 20 | TB | Some reserve development | Brandon Walton UDFA | Average |
| 21 | TEN | Some late opportunities | Jaelyn Duncan R6 | Average− |
| 22 | IND | Limited return | Blake Freeland R4 | Average− |
| 23 | NYG | Limited established success | developmental group | Below avg |
| 24 | WAS | Limited late-OT production | developmental group | Below avg |
| 25 | NO | Limited | Landon Young R6 | Below avg |
| 26 | MIA | Limited homegrown record | — | Below avg |
| 27 | JAX | Limited | — | Below avg |
| 28 | CAR | Limited | — | Below avg |
| 29 | ATL | Limited | — | Below avg |
| 30 | ARI | Limited | — | Below avg |
| 31 | CIN | Little recent evidence | — | Below avg |
| 32 | DET | Little D3/UDFA OT evidence | — | Below avg |
The Shanahan tree has done really well here with that wide outside zone blocking system. Maybe that system just makes it easier— warrants more research