yimyammer
shitless classpainter
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2019
- Messages
- 3,271
my response was to your comment:So you think testing every single person in the country is an option? So what do we do with the people that test pos+ for the antibodies but never get sick? Do we demand everyone they come in contact with quarantine for 2 weeks? Who is going to enforce this? And why does anyone think we will go along with it?
Yea fuck that, I have no doubt that would be abused by the tyrants in power
I was pointing out the potential value to being tested, not telling you to, judging you for not, etcWhy test people who don't have symptoms is my guess. Cmon I mean I'm not going to get tested because I'm not sick...
I also didn't say testing everyone in the country is an option, not sure where you got that impression (I speculated it would be nice and admitted it was a pipe dream because no such cheap home test exists). I also said the testing loses its value rather quickly once exposed to others who may have the virus.
I think there is value to testing if you're in a circle you can control well like I am in so If I knew I had it and was asymptomatic, I would work extra hard not to expose others I care about to infection, I would think anyone would want that until a vaccine is created and available. Inversely, if my girlfriend and I were both tested and either already had it or didn't have it, we could start hanging out more.
The device I mentioned is theoretical and what I envisioned is for home use and not connected to anyone or government. If you don't want one, fine, I would because it would help me manage my own risk and my risk of exposing others. Anything could be abused by a so called "tyrant", it doesnt mean it still shouldn't exist (imo).
And if its proven that those who have been sick (& have antibodies) are no longer contagious, then testing would reveal those who are not contagious and who's antibodies could be donated to help treat the infected
The bottom line is we have a difficult problem to manage and need to use every reasonable tool we can find to manage things until a vaccine is created or herd amenity is achieved.
Hand waiving it all away and doing nothing or fearing doing something because it could be abused by a tyrant is currently not a view I hold, ymmv