You are the only one talking about the outcome of the play (and the play after that) to determine if it was the right or wrong call, that is hindsight.
No, I'm not using the later outcomes to say it was the right call or the wrong call. I'm not even really weighing in on whether it was the right call or the wrong call. You seem to be misunderstanding that.
I'm saying that it's proof that the call to pass on second and 1, whether right/smart or wrong/dumb
at the time the call was made, did not have the effect of hurting us. We could have achieved on the very next down on third and 1 (and did, when Prescott achieved it by rushing for more than 2 yards) the very thing you were trying to accomplish on second down. It made the second down call moot, even if it was a dumb call on second and 1.
I'm also saying there is the possibility that a run on second and 1 simply scores on second and 1. We don't know the outcome of a hypothetical run on second and 1. We may call a different type of run than the one Prescott play-actioned away from on second and 1, if we call a run instead of a pass.
The pass was the wrong call. If they run it and they score, fine. Would the outcome of the game have changed? Probably not, but it was the right call. Throwing a pass there was a stupid, wrong, asinine call.
If they run it and score on 2nd and 1, we are actually in about a 3-4 second worse position (ie, 3-4 seconds more time left on the clock for the Packers).
What you are calling the "right call" is because you think, based on the odds, it was the best chance to pick up the first down and run more time off the clock.
You are free to think that. It may well have been.
However, you comparing it to being the same level of wrong as a "punt" is stupid. As I said, there are degrees of calls being good or bad, better or worse.
Calling a pass on second down in this situation probably wasn't the smartest move, I have conceded.
I don't think it was as bad as some are making it out to be, however.
And of course, there's no proof that it actually cost us the game, as I explained above.