Equal rights isn't even the issue with this program mindset. It's more like a consequence reliever. What was done with the Africans who were forced into slavery is completely abhorrent. I think most will agree on that. The question now is are subsequent generations of the nation responsible to try to appease this act by rewarding subsequent generations of the victims? Is there actual justice in reporation to current American citizens?"Equal rights"
The quotes around the words were meant to signify the use of sarcasm. I completely agree with you.Equal rights isn't even the issue with this program mindset. It's more like a consequence reliever. What was done with the Africans who were forced into slavery is completely abhorrent. I think most will agree on that. The question now is are subsequent generations of the nation responsible to try to appease this act by rewarding subsequent generations of the victims? Is there actual justice in reporation to current American citizens?
If this is an acceptable method of redemption for the acts of national ancestors then how are similiar issues such as the treatment to the Native American Indians to be dealt with or has the Native American already been made right by the acts of the Federal Government? Then there is the question of why should succeeding generations of the Africans and Native American benefit at all since the were not victums of the wrongful acts?
The Federal Government has already mandated equal rights as the remedy for all citizens of this country so what is left to do? Am I responsible for the historical acts and are the descendants of the victums entitled to something from me?
Equal rights are a noble goal, but literally unacheivable. All we can do is try and dismantle the things that are in place, and are being reinforced, to trap minorities in cycles of poverty. Until we get rid of the prison pipeline, the "war on drugs" (aka Nixon's war on blacks), the jack booted oppression of blacks in inner cities by police, and the segregation of public schools, I think free college for black Americans is the least we could do."Equal rights"
And, you are doing nothing but making the problem worse. "Feed a man a fish versus teach a man to fish" rings true.Equal rights are a noble goal, but literally unacheivable. All we can do is try and dismantle the things that are in place, and are being reinforced, to trap minorities in cycles of poverty. Until we get rid of the prison pipeline, the "war on drugs" (aka Nixon's war on blacks), the jack booted oppression of blacks in inner cities by police, and the segregation of public schools, I think free college for black Americans is the least we could do.
You 'teach a man to fish' by sending him to college, you send a man to college by eliminating as best as possible the financial hurdles that are in place due to discrimination. No one ever benefitted from paying their own 5 to 6 figure tuition costs, they just ended up further behind the 8-ball when it was time to start a career. There's a reason why kids who grow up in luxury have a much much higher chance of graduating with diploma, money matters.And, you are doing nothing but making the problem worse. "Feed a man a fish versus teach a man to fish" rings true.
You "teach a man" to be dependent on the government. The word equal doesn't mean what it used to. In either race relations or gender relations.You 'teach a man to fish' by sending him to college, you send a man to college by eliminating as best as possible the financial hurdles that are in place due to discrimination. No one ever benefitted from paying their own 5 to 6 figure tuition costs, they just ended up further behind the 8-ball when it was time to start a career. There's a reason why kids who grow up in luxury have a much much higher chance of graduating with diploma, money matters.
Because it isn't equal. In the same way it wasn't equal during segregation, people said it was, because they liked to make themselves feel better, but legitimately they were propping up an incredibly oppressive system that treated blacks as second class citizens. Which is what "equal rights" means today, delusion based on willful ignorance of oppression.You "teach a man" to be dependent on the government. The word equal doesn't mean what it used to. In either race relations or gender relations.
So, how far do we go? We give college for free. We already have affirmative action, so there is an advantage there. We already give money to the poor, so do we give more? Do we make their mortgage interest free, or pay it altogether? Do we make them tax free so they don't have to pay sales or income tax? Oh wait, we already do that second one. Do we give them vehicles to get to work?Because it isn't equal. In the same way it wasn't equal during segregation, people said it was, because they liked to make themselves feel better, but legitimately they were propping up an incredibly oppressive system that treated blacks as second class citizens. Which is what "equal rights" means today, delusion based on willful ignorance of oppression.
A lot of people in this country cruise to success on the strength of their parents wealth. No one thinks anything of it. That "help" is just what a parent is expected to do for their kid, if they can.So, how far do we go? We give college for free. We already have affirmative action, so there is an advantage there. We already give money to the poor, so do we give more? Do we make their mortgage interest free, or pay it altogether? Do we make them tax free so they don't have to pay sales or income tax? Oh wait, we already do that second one. Do we give them vehicles to get to work?
Honestly, I would be insulted if you told me you had to give me something for me to succeed in life.
Loaning people money and paying them for a job they do is not even close to giving people stuff. Try again.A lot of people in this country cruise to success on the strength of their parents wealth. No one thinks anything of it. That "help" is just what a parent is expected to do for their kid, if they can.
That's why people trapped in cycles of poverty need more help, because the (rapidly diminishing) wealth of the middle class that lets parents help their kids succeed was intentionally withheld from blacks for generations.
It's cute when people pretend success is acheived through independence. As if they weren't educated by other peoples dollars, lived in other peoples homes, worked for other people, got mortgages and built businesses on loan with other peoples money. Every successful person in this country has about a dozen moments where their entire life would have been derailed if they couldn't find a landlord that would lease to them, a bank that would loan to them, someone who was willing to take a chance on them. Anyone who truly believes they're independent is deluded.
You seriously don't think you've been given something for you to succeed?So, how far do we go? We give college for free. We already have affirmative action, so there is an advantage there. We already give money to the poor, so do we give more? Do we make their mortgage interest free, or pay it altogether? Do we make them tax free so they don't have to pay sales or income tax? Oh wait, we already do that second one. Do we give them vehicles to get to work?
Honestly, I would be insulted if you told me you had to give me something for me to succeed in life.
By my parents, sure. By the government? Not so much. If you are trying to equate the two, you are way offbase.You seriously don't think you've been given something for you to succeed?
Human beings are born completely dependent, and though you might have been "born poor" you have been given multiple things.
You are going to school as a result of having access to the GI Bill right? If you didn't have that avenue would you think you were entitled to a college education simply because you couldn't afford college? If you think so please state why you would be owed that right and who and why someone should be obligated to furnish it to you. Remember the government doesn't have any resources unless they tax someone or create a debt for the tax payer.. Now who owes you that right.A lot of people in this country cruise to success on the strength of their parents wealth. No one thinks anything of it. That "help" is just what a parent is expected to do for their kid, if they can.
That's why people trapped in cycles of poverty need more help, because the (rapidly diminishing) wealth of the middle class that lets parents help their kids succeed was intentionally withheld from blacks for generations.
It's cute when people pretend success is acheived through independence. As if they weren't educated by other peoples dollars, lived in other peoples homes, worked for other people, got mortgages and built businesses on loan with other peoples money. Every successful person in this country has about a dozen moments where their entire life would have been derailed if they couldn't find a landlord that would lease to them, a bank that would loan to them, someone who was willing to take a chance on them. Anyone who truly believes they're independent is deluded.
I think education should be affordable it's no secret that a 4 year degree used to be the price of a car, but now it's the price of a mortgage. I don't think anyone owed me my college education, although universities that take tax dollars owe their citizens more than they're offering.You are going to school as a result of having access to the GI Bill right? If you didn't have that avenue would you think you were entitled to a college education simply because you couldn't afford college? If you think so please state why you would be owed that right and who and why someone should be obligated to furnish it to you. Remember the government doesn't have any resources unless they tax someone or create a debt for the tax payer.. Now who owes you that right.
How were you educated? I assume the government paid your way through high school, did that dependence on the gov't mess you up?By my parents, sure. By the government? Not so much. If you are trying to equate the two, you are way offbase.
So, they didn't give GI bills to black people that served? I'm seriously asking.I think education should be affordable it's no secret that a 4 year degree used to be the price of a car, but now it's the price of a mortgage. I don't think anyone owed me my college education, although universities that take tax dollars owe their citizens more than they're offering.
But I should mention that I'm a the second GI Bill recipient in my family. My grandfather got his after WW2. At the same time as some black grandfather was being refused the education he earned, mine was getting a bachelors. When someone was unable to find a good job for lack of a degree, my grandfather got a job as an insurance adjuster that kept him comfortable and sent all his kids to college. When I grew up, my mom, who had a degree in education from Texas Tech, homeschooled me through the 5th grade. By the time I went to public school I was way ahead of my peers and was demolishing standardized tests. Even though my parents couldn't afford to pay for my college, I got waivers granted to enlist despite some breathing problems I had, on the strength of the 96 I scored on the ASVAB.
Without all of that, I may have never made it into the military, and never been able to go to college. All starting with a foundation of my grandfather having a skin color that allowed him to go to college.
Uhh, school taxes paid my way through high school. So, in essence, my parents paid for it. Not sure how the two relate.How were you educated? I assume the government paid your way through high school, did that dependence on the gov't mess you up?