Sturm: The Parker Report – Taken To School By Niners

dpf1123

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
3,424

The Parker Report – Taken To School By Niners​

Kyle Shanahan was the next in line to teach a clinic at the expense of the Cowboys’ defense.​

Bob Sturm
18 minutes ago




This game, we know the defense is the lead story, so they go first.

  • Overall Defensive Evaluation vs San Francisco
  • We have never seen it this bad across the board
  • But, a tied-season-high in sacks!
  • And, Quinnen Williams is still a superstar who plays like it
  • Film Study
  • Splash Plays
OK, let’s begin.



OVERALL DEFENSIVE EVALUATION​

We are wondering if this will be called “The Parker Report” for much longer.

Dallas entered the game as one of the league’s worst defenses and then played the single worst defensive game in franchise history (arguably). What is not arguable is that the red arrows below demonstrate how this was objectively the worst defensive performance of 2026 – which is a 10-game stretch where we continue to lower the bar with one massive disaster after the next.



Most yards (584) ever allowed in a Dallas Cowboys home game. Ever. Most yards per play (9.4) that Dallas has allowed since 1998 when they played the Broncos up in Denver. Most Average Gain Per Pass (11.2) since 2024 and New Orleans and Derek Carr, somehow.

Most 60-yard touchdowns in one game for the first time in 20 years of any NFL game? Apparently so. Well, like we said yesterday, even the Cowboys routinely do not allow three of those in an entire season, let alone in about an hour of time Sunday.

Things are very bad.

We have never seen it this bad across the board​

It was so bad and now it seems time is ticking on the amount of time left in Christian Parker’s first attempt at being a NFL Defensive Coordinator. We know very well that the Cowboys left their comfort zone to hire him and we also know that they will retreat to what they know (experienced coaches and safe hires that often offer retreads) if the results do not improve quickly.

We now concede that changes could happen before this is even published. It is that dire that Dallas could reasonably pull the plug on the entire project as soon as this week. Studies will be done someday to figure out how Christian Parker went from the savior of Dallas defense to the cause of this season where they have gotten even worse in record time. He was widely adored and clearly seems now widely blamed for having no solutions to the many defensive problems.

It is all very depressing, to be honest.

Let’s look at three plays up here at the top that summarize how the Cowboys were being set up by Kyle Shanahan and the Niners on Sunday and didn’t even know it.

I was really interested in Shanahan’s press conference answer about the Deebo Samuel reverse touchdown and it sent me down this rabbit hole:

On the design of Deebo Samuel’s 70-yard reverse.

“That was just a reverse. We’ve been trying—we called it earlier in the game, and we messed something up on it and ended up having a bad play. So we came back to it in the second half and we got the right look. I mean, no one was there when we came around, got him in a good blitz, and it was awesome. I didn’t think Trent was going to see the guy at the last second. Trent just punched this guy, just kind of stunned the guy. And then Deebo was Deebo. I mean, I think a lot of people are going to get yards on there, but not many people are going to go all 70, and that’s what Deebo does. And I heard Brock got some blocks in the play, too.”
OK, so, the quote I heard was, “we called it earlier in the game, and we messed something up on it and ended up having a bad play.” Obviously, I had to go find it.

Here it is:

Play No. 1​

2Q - 4:04 - 1-10-SF 24 - B.Purdy sacked at SF 18 for -6 yards (J.Bullard).​


This is actually a Cowboys sack, but I want you to watch two players. The RB which is Kaelon Black and the WR down at the bottom which is Deebo Samuel. These two guys are about to run that reverse to this side, but the QB Brock Purdy goes the other way. I assume Brock is wrong here, but who knows? The point is, this is that reverse. They were going to run it here in the 2nd Quarter, but the play was aborted. Keep that in mind as we move to the next play.

Play No. 2​

3Q - 12:18 - 1-10-DAL 25 - K.Black left end for 25 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


Watch 44-Kyle Juszczyk. He will lead you to the action here and that is the eye-candy that alerts the defense where the play is headed. This play is that Kaelon Black Touchdown that probably had nothing to do with the upcoming reverse, except it showed how Dallas was not looking terribly full of hustle and energy to get to the ball. Watch 90-Bullard and 7-Gary and heck, half the defense sort of half-heartedly jog in the general direction of the ball. Then, of course, watch Black truck Caleb Downs and Cobie Durant and other than the DB’s, nobody looked terribly inspired to go help out and Black waltzes into the end zone. You know that they were scolded for that lack of effort by coaches and teammates and would do much better on the next possession.

Well, the Kyle Shanahan knows that, too. And will use that “better effort” against themselves on the next sequence.

Play No. 3​

3Q - 7:13 - 1-10-SF 30 - D.Samuel left end for 70 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


So, now you take Play 1 and Play 2 and add some elements together and that brings us to the Play 3 of this trilogy. First, we have Juszczyk leading us to the action. Then, we have the Cowboys all fired up to chase down the plays with maximum energy. Then, we have Black and Deebo to the bottom of the screen and the defense is determined to do better. Watch the backside pursuit from 41-Houston and 93-Garcia. They are hauling as fast as they can to chase Black down (who doesn’t have the ball). If you pause the tape at about 0:05, you will see ten of the eleven defenders for the Cowboys on the wrong side of the hash marks as the 49ers have Joey Porter out-numbered 7-to-1. How do you think the rest of this play is going to go?

The picture below will tell the story:



It was always a trap. From the moment Shanahan saw the first two plays, he was always setting up this one. The Cowboys were just a prop in the play.

It would not be the only time in the game we saw a coaching advantage for the opponents, but it demonstrates how far away this defense is at the moment. We just showed two touchdowns that were both scored with almost no resistance. There is no way to sugarcoat that.

Nor, can we sugar coat the red numbers below:



It is historically bad. We should point out that Dallas chose to play an awful lot of man coverage in this game – easily the most of the season with 54%. Given that San Francisco had a 64% success rate with the pass might indicate how well that went.

Everything was bad - except another five-sack performance and much better run defense on a down-to-down basis. Of course, giving up three touchdown runs like they did of substantial distances does not help the numbers, but most of the 49ers 29 runs were actually pretty well-defended (which is how we calculate success rate).

The drive chart was really something, though. Six different touchdown drives and all of them were at least 71 yards long.



That means no short fields and tons and tons of yardage. In fact, a record amount of yardage in the history of the Dallas Cowboys for any home game they have ever played seems to speak volumes. In particular, very few stops until it was pretty much too late. And even then, they didn’t get the stop they needed – more on that in a moment.

But, a tied-season-high in sacks!​

For the second time in three games, Dallas has five sacks in a game. Of course, they have lost both of these home games, so we don’t know what to do with this stat, but when we look at these five plays from Sunday, it is worth noting that several do appear to be coverage sacks where the line is being collapsed from all directions as Purdy is waiting for the play to develop.


Almost all the interior guys are getting things done. 99-Overton, 90-Bullard and 92-Quinnen Williams are getting things done constantly. 7-Gary and 41-Houston do get pressures and disruptions. We just wish the young edges, Malachi Lawrence and Donovan Ezeiruaku were healthy and impactful. But, it is what it is and the pressure is improving.

Now, time for our weekly feature, it seems:

Quinnen Williams is still a superstar who plays like it​


I refuse to let this slide. Quinnen had about a dozen plays where he was bossing the action again and is just a joy to watch. He deserves to be an All-Pro, but it is a tough case to make on a defense this poor. What a player who is giving you tremendous effort and tremendous results. He provides hope for what might be at some point.

OK, now, on to our film. We covered a lot of the bad stuff above, but plenty more below.

FILM STUDY​

1Q - 7:43 - 2-4-DAL 31 - B.Purdy pass short left to G.Kittle to DAL 11 for 20 yards (E.Garcia).​


This play is a great example of what the Niners do to you. It is 2nd and 4, so their entire playsheet is in play. Dallas will play man coverage here and the 49ers will show them motion to the right and the have double screen options with the RB to the right and George Kittle to the left. Once all the receivers clear out and the motion goes one way, Kittle lets Rashan Gary go on the rush and now he has nothing but space to navigate because his man, 14-Bell, runs into 71-Trent Williams and is disposed of quickly. Gain of 20 yards on a pass of about 2 yards.

1Q - 7:01 - 1-10-DAL 11 - B.Purdy pass short right to D.Samuel for 11 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


On the very next play, let’s run a quick bubble to Deebo Samuel with several OL leaking out to clear the space. This is the first TD and the first untouched TD of the day. There will be more, unfortunately. All the movement from George Kittle draws the safety to the other-side of the field. When you want to play man, then you better have 11 players defending because the 49ers will stretch you out and expose your flanks quickly.

1Q - 0:19 -3-7-SF 38 - B.Purdy pass incomplete short left to G.Kittle.​


3rd and 7, here is the Joey Porter story again. He played his season-high in snaps and is now over 200 snaps as a Dallas Cowboys DB and has given up a total of 19 yards in receiving this year in 12 targets. Here is one with George Kittle and he is physical and aggressive and seems to get some latitude from the officials in these spots. I think Porter is excellent, but obviously, his availability is being constantly monitored. But, that is probably the elite corner you need to build a defense.

2Q - 12:02 - 3-12-SF 39 - B.Purdy pass deep left to K.Allen ran ob at DAL 38 for 23 yards.​


3rd and 12 and you would sure love to get off the field here. Quinnen Williams has him for a sack and as great as Quinnen would be, if he could finish a few more of these, he might get to 12 sacks this year (like he did in 2022). Anyway, once the pass rush flushes Purdy out, he must find Keenan Allen who is running away from Caleb Downs. Downs has a tough angle to navigate here, but can Purdy make this throw on the run? Easily. That is an impressive QB play right there.

2Q - 2:43 - 3-8-SF 26 - B.Purdy pass short right to C.McCaffrey for 74 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


Again, I was not always a Brock Purdy believer, but this is such great QB play that we must give him his full due. The blitz by Caleb Downs should have done him in, but he side-stepped it. Meanwhile, McCaffrey appears responsible to pick up Downs and missed him, but then decided to become a solution for Purdy who is being chased by 50-Shemar James. When I saw him pull up and find a receiver in stride, I instantly thought back to his big time play in 2022 in the playoff game in San Francisco against the Cowboys. Hits CMC in stride and he is gone for 74-yards, again, untouched. Truly sensational and from a Dallas standpoint, I am not sure the solution other than Downs has to get Purdy down.


Here is the play from the 2nd half of that playoff game in San Francisco where he resets and fires a strike to a player in stride. Again, Purdy doesn’t seem to miss these very often. He is much better than I first thought. The location on that throw to Kittle was a much smaller window and, of course, he was a rookie in a tied playoff game. I suppose the clues where there, if you looked hard enough.

2Q - 0:21 - 3-2-DAL 49 - B.Purdy pass incomplete deep left to G.Kittle (M.Hooker).​


This is another close-call right before halftime that saved Dallas some points. We seldom talk much about Malik Hooker, but I think his last month or so has been pretty solid. He probably got there early, but it was a close play and he got the benefit of the doubt on a corner to Kittle who surely has some thoughts on how he isn’t getting many calls on this day.

4Q - 14:16 - 3-2-SF 40 - B.Purdy pass short left to C.McCaffrey to DAL 46 for 14 yards (C.Downs).​


As you probably are now well aware of, the best two receivers that the 49ers have had for quite a while are their TE Kittle and their RB McCaffrey. When you have so many interchangeable parts, you are playing position-less football and are the cutting edge of innovation in this sport. This is why if I could steal any coach, it would be Kyle. He is just on another level. Anyway, here is what you do on 3rd and short. Motion out your RB to a WR spot, match him up against a safety with an option route and then move the chains because McCaffrey is not losing this battle and if the throw is there, it is a wrap. Caleb Downs is learning how tough this league is and he will be fine, but the 49ers were looking for him trying to matchup with the best in the business.

4Q - 11:34 - 1-10-DAL 16 - C.McCaffrey left tackle for 16 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


This run is just so demoralizing. Dallas has so many DL on the field that there should not be this much space to chop through the front. But, give the 49ers credit - especially 71-Williams for getting 92-Williams out of the way. After that, the Cowboys 2nd and 3rd level defenders are all on the ground. I assure you that bodies on the ground is a sign that you just got steamrolled. This is the best run defense you could call and it was crushed. Tough scene.

Finally, the play that will be talked about for a long time as perhaps the last straw for Christian Parker as the top man for this defense:

4Q - 3:32 - 2-10-SF 34 - B.Purdy pass short right to C.McCaffrey for 66 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


The Cowboys blitz six and the 49ers do not keep TE or RB in to pick them up. So, the Cowboys are calling a very risky blitz with Cover 0 behind it and the 49ers are calling their bluff and calling a very risky counter with five guys in route vs a six man blitz. Either the blitz will get to Purdy before he can carve you up, or you are about to get carved. So, yes, you can argue that Von Miller on Christian McCaffrey is the problem here, but actually the problem is that you send six rushers vs five blockers and do not even come close to their QB.

Now, why is Von Miller on CMC? Well, it appears a coverage where they have Juszczyk and McCaffrey in a banjo coverage with Joey Porter and Miller. Whoever goes inside will be the edge’s responsibility and who ever goes outside will be Porter. Everyone else is being cleared out to the left by Kittle and that put Miller on an island with the great RB. Bad idea. Of course, this seems like the perfect call against a six man blitz, but if you are blitzing more than they have in, you should be hitting the QB as he releases the ball. Instead, nobody even is close to Purdy. It is tough to defend anything about this call except the question, “how did they know?” It was as if they were in the Dallas huddle. Shanahan won the day and this one sealed the game in somewhat comedic fashion. Another untouched TD.

SPLASH PLAYS vs San Francisco​



Some good work was done, but they could never get the takeaway and they allowed way too many explosives that cancelled everything out, easily.

SEASON LEADERBOARD​

Quinnen Williams is off in his own area code.



CONCLUSIONS:​

Dallas played a Super Bowl contender and it was very clear and very depressing how far away they are defensively. Changes will be made and we wait to see what those are, but at the end of the day, we are seeing that they are running out of ideas.

It is a bad defense and now morale is taking it lower. There are some good pieces, but even the slight strides in improvement are being overrun with the big plays that lose games.

We will get to the offense tomorrow, but we know why this team is losing. They can’t stop anybody. They can’t stop this outfit, but they also couldn’t stop Tampa Bay or Arizona in the last three home game. Arizona scored 33 on Dallas on November 1st and have scored just nine points since.

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F08f760f7-dbea-49fc-be4b-67288081d4f7_1600x240.png


Dallas has work to do on defense and we will continue to track their progress, but man, we regret to inform everyone that we have never seen anything like what 2026 has dropped on us.
 
Back
Top Bottom