dpf1123
DCC 4Life
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2013
- Messages
- 3,424
The Morning After Week 10 – Explosives Detonated
In a record-breaking day, the San Francisco 49ers left no doubt how this battle would end.
Bob Sturm3 hours ago
There are certain matchups where even those of us who are filled with optimism have a hard time dealing with. This week was one of those times for yours truly.
In the case of the San Francisco 49ers of modern vintage against our frustrating Dallas Cowboys, we were once again left with no doubt.
The Dallas Cowboys presently – all decade, that is – still have no answer for one of their most decorated and historic rivals.
The 49ers won easily on Sunday, 46-40, and have now won five straight in this series. They did so on Sunday by scoring five touchdowns in seven possessions to take a small deficit and turning it into a laugher in little time. Dallas performed some cosmetics late to increase fantasy football statistics, but let’s not in any way be fooled by the final spread – this thing was not a very close contest again and the problems may be bigger than we first imagined.
Dallas is now 4-6 and have lost three consecutive home games as the season quickly spirals out of any cloud of optimism that accompanied the Cowboys into their campaign. That belief in this crew has been stomped out with yet another failure in trying to win even two consecutive games in a year’s time, despite all of the changes and supposed improvements. It is pretty clear to all who dedicate time and interest in their direction that they are still miles away from comparing with an actual championship contender.
And, please make no mistake. The 49ers are definitely a championship contender. They did plenty on both sides of the ball to win this matchup – in front of a crowd that appeared to be supporting the road team as much or more than the Cowboys – to feel that this game was not as close as the final score would indicate. When they took a 38-19 lead with 11:26 to go in the game, it had been a thorough whooping in every department. Dallas would rally late – like they often do – to accumulate 21 more points that frankly flatter their effort.
The reality is simple – the defense is now at an even lower point than we ever imagined. Through 10 games, they have actually lowered the bar quite a bit across the board from 2024 and 2025. Those were two seasons when the defense was said to be the main focus of blame and requiring immediate firings. Well, now they are actually even worse in many categories and trending worse across the board.
Let’s start with the overall carnage of Sunday, where once again the Christian Parker defense was beaten up in nearly every way, despite 5 sacks.
First, they allowed 584 yards and 46 points.
Now, I am not sure if you have perspective on what that means, but let’s tell you this way: They have never given up 584 yards in any home game they have ever played. Heck, they have only given up 550 in one other home game that was ever played in North Texas – the Saints in 2012 rolled up 562 at AT&T Stadium (but at least they required overtime to do so).
They have given up 46 points before in a home game – in fact, you can probably name many of the other eight times it has happened. The Randy Moss game, the 2007 Patriots visit, the famous Broncos win here in 2013, The Browns in 2020, the Packers playoff game in January of 2024, and Dan Campbell’s visit in the fall of 2024 were several of them.
But, to combine them both? Well, you witnessed new dubious Dallas Cowboys history. In fact, it only rivals the worst ever road game against the Saints down in New Orleans in 2013 as the worst franchise defensive performance of all-time. That day, the Saints rolled up 625 yards on Monte Kiffin’s famous defense (for all the wrong reasons).
So, there you have it. Yesterday, was historically bad in just total volume of awful defense.
But, wait, there is more that might suggest that yesterday was the absolute worst defensive game in Cowboys history. Now, they have played 1,092 games in franchise history, so how can I make that claim?
Well, perhaps you will recall that yesterday, the San Francisco 49ers managed to score three different 60+ yard touchdowns on the same day!
Here, I will prove it:
Brock Purdy to Christian McCaffrey for 74 yards in the second Quarter, the Deebo Samuel end around for 70 yards in the third Quarter, and then the Brock Purdy to McCaffrey while Von Miller chases for 66 yards in the fourth Quarter.
Three different long touchdowns from their own side of the field of over 60 yards IN THE SAME GAME?
How rare is that? First, it hadn’t happened anywhere in the NFL since 2000. In addition, the Matt Eberflus Cowboys of 2025 only allowed one of those plays all-season long when Washington scored one on Christmas Day from 72 yards.
The 2024 defense had a bad year and only allowed three. The 2023 Dan Quinn defense allowed two for the full year. Heck, the 2001 Dave Campo defense did not allow a single touchdown all season of this distance. Neither did the 1996 defense. The 1992 defense had one play of that distance for the full season.
But, this team managed three in the same day. Three!
At a certain point of this team’s ineptness, we might have to pull the plug on this project. I just don’t know if we can keep sinking to new depths with this defensive group that is largely different, but also even worse than the 2025 version before it. And that defense was even worse than the 2024 version before them. It just keeps finding new depths to fall.
This is no way should exclude the offense from some blame for Sunday, but the main reason we assumed Dallas would have almost no chance to win this game – despite the oddsmakers having a very small advantage for the 49ers – is that we knew that Kyle Shanahan’s scheme is built to make disorganized defenses look silly. It is the misdirection and eye-candy that will help make things easy because the Cowboys will take themselves out of plays and leave wide open channels for huge gains. This is what they do better than anyone and it allows them to rack up explosive play after explosive play. We certainly preach the turnover differential being closely correlated to winning and losing in the NFL (which the 49ers won, 2-0, on Sunday). But, many coaches also look carefully at the “explosive play” differential on 20+ yard plays. It was also heavy to the Niners, 8-5, with Dallas getting several of its big plays when the game was already in the bag.
That is what makes the Niners so terrifying. They get the production without the risk of turnovers. They roll up nearly 600 yards, but almost no damage is done with deep throws. Sure, Brock Purdy can hit some of those throws, but the carnage was with safe throws behind huge convoys of blockers or wide swaths of real estate.

Just watch Dallas take itself out of plays in the sort of way where you hand them the rope and they will form their own noose all by themselves. It is what well-coached teams at every level will do to poorly-coached teams.
But, then, we see that it isn’t just coaching at all. It is Purdy so comfortable in the system that he knows it the initial play breaks down, there are brilliant pieces all around him who know from their years in the system where to go and what to do to allow improvisational masterpieces to be born. The second quarter score to McCaffrey was just play-making brilliance from the former 7th-round QB who is now as composed as it gets.
The RB was not even in the play as his coach Kyle Shanahan said in postgame:
“Christian was unbelievable on it. They actually blitzed, had a guy in the A-gap who got out of there, then had to go to the backside, picked up the blitz from the backside. Then Brock broke out, and I have no idea how Christian was blocking the blitz in the A-gap and ended up where he was. So I’m excited to see it on the plane.”
We don’t have to wait to see it.
Caleb Downs is coming on the blitz and has a shot, but Purdy makes him miss. When he does, McCaffrey emerges from the traffic to give his QB something to work with. That high-IQ decision leads to a game-breaking moment where the 49ers take the lead with 2:26 to go in the first half. As we know know, they would never look back. That complete improv moment is what started the avalanche.
They are so smart as a team and they drag you into the deep water for three hours to see how strong your resolve is. How long do you want to try to hit with us? How long do you want to try to tackle with us? They are the standard that any team – including this one here in Dallas should aspire to. The 49ers have a known style and players that fit that style. They keep targeting their types of players so they can be plugged in and replace the roles of those who have left. Rookie RB Kaelon Black is the latest example of their type, as he runs right over two Dallas DBs on one of the other “short” TDs that did not travel 66 yards or more. His only went for 25 yards.
Meanwhile, the Dallas offense will surely be defended all week with the “when you score 40 points, it ought to be enough to win” defense teams, but I am less enthused about that claim.
Down 38-19 in the fourth quarter is not keeping up. Scoring touchdowns when the game is essentially over and the 49ers are just trying to get to the end should not impress. It is a trademark of Cowboys football for the last 20 years as Tony Romo and Dak Prescott both have double-digit occasions of furious stat-packing rallies that fall short. We have seen them all and unless they actually complete the rally, most all of them should righteously be put in the “garbage time” category.
From the 1st Quarter until the McCaffrey 16-yarder early in the fourth quarter, Dallas was out-scored, 31-9. I’m sorry, but if your opponent scores 31 points in the section of the game where you score a single touchdown (missed the extra point) and a field goal, your hands are not clean of blame. The two punts and the interception as well as settling for a field goal are leaving all sorts of points on the board. In a game like this, the offense knows its job – to be the best offense on the field. There are only two teams, so you simply have to match or outmatch your one opponent in red. And this Cowboys offensive performance did not come close. They finished 2nd in every single category against the Niners.
Dak Prescott and the offense are not blameless at all. Brock Purdy outplayed him in every career matchup they have ever had and that continues on this day. It is a real shame that he wasn’t sharper, but they live in his kitchen. Too many wasted drives and points left unsecured should prohibit anyone from claiming the offense doesn’t share a major role in this mess.
Too many big plays for the enemy. Not enough moments of execution from the home side. Then a stadium overrun by 49ers fans makes the humiliation even more of a stinger, as we see what once seemed like a home fortress where teams did not succeed in this building has turned into a place everyone wins.
Dallas won 16 games in a row at home between September of 2022 and that Green Bay playoff loss in January of 2024. 16 in a row. Since that day? They have played 22 home games in front of their unconvinced fans and have won just seven of them.
7-14-1 in the last three seasons at home and 5-7-1 since Brian Schottenheimer was brought in to attempt to improve off of Mike McCarthy.
At this point, we are not sure where to find the Schottenheimer or Parker metrics that offer optimism. In an effort to upgrade, the evidence suggests they are worse in nearly everything. The case for belief in 2026 is quickly disappearing and with it is the belief in the current Cowboys regime.
Sunday was a massive dose of reality and unfortunately, we all saw it coming. But, knowing what was coming and being able to do something about it are clearly two different issues for this year’s Dallas Cowboys.
They were swept away with ease by those 49ers who look like they have big plans for their January and it is definitely not going to include another coaching search. Dallas, on the other hand, appears headed that way – again.
