- Joined
- Apr 7, 2013
- Messages
- 65,996
I wouldn't give him shit for it, since there's a risk reward calculation that you could defend the decision with, especially given you'd have almost no confidence in the defense stopping SF from getting a first down.
But I do understand the criticism. Had they kicked away and made them punt you get the ball back in much better field position than they wound up getting. They would have had a legitimate shot on that last possession.
Onside kicks are just becoming so futile in the NFL. With that being said, I don't think there is a right answer. You kickoff and hope to pin them back. But it potentially wastes more time on the clock from the return. It maybe gives you a better shot at a returnable punt. But even then it's still long odds.
That game was lost by all the decisions leading up to that. It wasn't lost because we picked an onside kick or kicked off. Either way we lose and either way the decision gets questioned.