2026 Random Cowboys Stuff Thread...

Figures stepping outside their comfort zone by hiring a supposed young genius would be a complete miss. Just totally snakebit


I know a lot of people including people here have advocated for that but I've never really been a fan of that. Give me the proven veteran more often than not.

People see guys like McVey or McDonald succeed in their first try and get enamored with that but for every McVey there are probably 10 young up and comers who fail.
 
At least Pettine did have that tie-in with Schottenheimer at the Jets. So this isn't as totally disjointed as it could be if, say, you had to promote a guy the HC didn't even know and was hired 100% because of the DC.

In the end I doubt any of this matters, because BS is terrible also and IMO most likely will be canned after the season... assuming they don't pull their heads out of their asses and start looking like an NFL football team.
 
I know a lot of people including people here have advocated for that but I've never really been a fan of that. Give me the proven veteran more often than not.

People see guys like McVey or McDonald succeed in their first try and get enamored with that but for every McVey there are probably 10 young up and comers who fail.

The thing is there weren't many clearly strong established guys available last year.

Jonathan Gannon?

Meh, he's worked out for GB but nobody here strongly preferred him to a less established guy.

If someone like Bowles was available, sure, but they weren't.
 
I know a lot of people including people here have advocated for that but I've never really been a fan of that. Give me the proven veteran more often than not.

People see guys like McVey or McDonald succeed in their first try and get enamored with that but for every McVey there are probably 10 young up and comers who fail.

Agreed 100%.
 
The thing is there weren't many clearly strong established guys available last year.

Jonathan Gannon?

Meh, he's worked out for GB but nobody here strongly preferred him to a less established guy.

If someone like Bowles was available, sure, but they weren't.


That's true, a lot of the main candidates were first timers.

Still, there was Gannon (full disclosure I wouldn't have wanted him at the time), Schwartz, Morris, and I think a couple other potential candidates who had actual experience. Even Leonhard had some experience as a DC in college.
 
Random thought, but if shit boy Schottenheimer is still here next year and Quinn is fired in DC, what are the chances we get some weird love triangle on the defensive staff between Pettine, Parker and Quinn?

Quinn and Schottenheimer are supposedly very close.
 
That's true, a lot of the main candidates were first timers.

Still, there was Gannon (full disclosure I wouldn't have wanted him at the time), Schwartz, Morris, and I think a couple other potential candidates who had actual experience. Even Leonhard had some experience as a DC in college.

Yea I think I had Schwartz and Morris above Parker, although I wasn't gung go on them.
 
I have no doubt that Parker will land on his feet as a secondary coach somewhere. And he will be better for it.


As soon as he walks out the door, he'll be better off. Of that, I have no doubt.
 
As soon as he walks out the door, he'll be better off. Of that, I have no doubt.

Yeah, I don't know how good the guy will or won't be, but I do know he came to one of the worst organizations possible for his first DC job.

Removing the X's and O's from it, a big part of his success/failure is getting the players' respect and commanding their attention. In Dallas, that's not even possible for the HC so just imagine how much harder it must be for a coordinator.

He needed to go somewhere that allowed the football aspect of things to function normally.
 
People see guys like McVey or McDonald succeed in their first try and get enamored with that but for every McVey there are probably 10 young up and comers who fail.

You also see some of them fail initially but then become great coordinators. I think it's a learning process but we don't have time to screw around with a guy learning on the job.
 
People see guys like McVey or McDonald succeed in their first try and get enamored with that but for every McVey there are probably 10 young up and comers who fail.
I think we talked about that at the time. For every McVay there are several Brandon Staleys, but when they flop people quickly forget them and it's like they never happened.
 
Back
Top Bottom