2025 NFL Draft Chatter

Status
Not open for further replies.
shoop said:
If both are gone and we are in the 18-20 range I’m not mad if they take Egbuka.
Click to expand...
There really is not a lot of difference to the wideouts where you say if one is there at 12, you take him. And that includes Golden. Problem is, if we wait, Jalen Tolbert continues to start.
 
Was just listening to a Fan spot from yesterday and Broaddus has Revel at #12 overall player (they double-checked to make sure they heard that right) and Burden at #10 overall. That's his rankings, not where he thinks the teams will take them.

:doh
 
Chocolate Lab said:
Was just listening to a Fan spot from yesterday and Broaddus has Revel at #12 overall player (they double-checked to make sure they heard that right) and Burden at #10 overall. That's his rankings, not where he thinks the teams will take them.

:doh
Click to expand...

That tracks considering that this dumbass came up as a scout in a completely dysfunctional organization. There's a reason Parcells immediately sent him on the first bus out of town, he's a moron.

I guarantee you that I'm a better talent evaluator than him, along with probably at least a handful of other posters.
 
Chocolate Lab said:
Was just listening to a Fan spot from yesterday and Broaddus has Revel at #12 overall player (they double-checked to make sure they heard that right) and Burden at #10 overall. That's his rankings, not where he thinks the teams will take them.

:doh
Click to expand...

I mean I get that they are his personal opinions and those are sometimes going to differ from what the reality on draft day is going to be. But his opinions usually suck, so there is that.

Like if I were coming up with a ranking I'm not going to put Mykel Williams high on my rankings just because I think an NFL team is going to make a mistake on him. I'd put him where I think he belongs and on draft day some other NFL team is going to make the mistake and not me. To me he is a second round type DE.

It's why when someone says Golden is a 15-20 type talent, I say list the 14 guys you'd rather have than Golden? I can't do it. It doesn't really matter where he would get drafted in a different draft class. What matters are this draft class and this team. I'm not taking Jalon Walker over Golden for example. I'm not taking Colston Loveland over him. I'm not taking Will Johnson over him.

Where it gets interesting is if you get into the Tyler Warren's or Will Campbell's. Guys that most have as top 10 talents. I don't really think either is a great fit for us. But if I was a different NFL team I might view those guys as better fits and have them higher than say Golden. I guess someone could say, that's not BPA. But don't you sort of set your list according to your NFL team? Not every player is a perfect fit for the scheme and situation of every NFL team. Nothing against Warren (I'm not as high on Will Campbell) I think he is a stellar TE. But I don't think he compliments Ferguson, he doesn't really add a dynamic element to our offense and I just think a player like Golden or McMillan would have a bigger impact for this team.
 
Last edited:
Cowboysrock55 said:
So this is a tricky one for me. If I were to make a draft board purely on ability I'd probably have Jeanty above those two. But if I look at the big picture of the draft and the insane amount of depth at RB, those WR's might be close enough to Jeanty that I'd say, I'll take the WR now and circle back to RB later. But for those who are pure, best player available, that kind of flies in the face of it.

Of course in this draft if I took purely BPA I might be taking a RB with every draft pick. Although D-line might not be far behind that for me.
Click to expand...
The way I look at it is, would I rather have Jeanty and Bech (or similar WR) or Golden and one of the Ohio State RBs?
 
NoDak said:
The way I look at it is, would I rather have Jeanty and Bech (or similar WR) or Golden and one of the Ohio State RBs?
Click to expand...

Yep and that's an easy answer for me. Give me the Ohio State kid and the stud WR. I actually prefer Judkins which tells you how much I care about which Ohio State RB it is considering he is the lower ranked guy by basically everyone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom