Sturm: Decoding Schotty Week 10 - Too Little, Too Late

dpf1123

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
3,428

Decoding Schotty Week 10 - Too Little, Too Late​

The offense helped fantasy football teams, but could not save themselves.​

Bob Sturm
4 hours ago




Here we go. Our objectives for today –

  • Overall Offensive Evaluation
  • The Furious, Fall-Short Comebacks - A Cowboys Tradition
  • A Breakdown of the QB Performance of Dak Prescott
  • Look at plenty of All-22 film and see what we can see.
Let’s dive in!



Offensive Evaluation – San Francisco​

Sunday was obviously a mixed bag for the offense. I say mixed bag, despite being surrounded by shouting voices that say the offense is completely blameless because they scored 40 points, had over 400 yards, and made a ton of big plays during the game.

But, it has to be mixed from this perspective. It has to be.

This offense is supposed to be the strong side of the ball – and they are – then we definitely will ask difficult things of them. With so much money of the salary cap dedicated to the offense, it is appropriate to ask difficult questions of that side of the ball when the game gets out of hand.

Everyone understands that this game and much of the last several years could be solved by having a competent defense, but that does not mean the offense can always just point over there and shrug. They are expected to play the game the same way a baseball team made up of great bats but no pitching should. Same with a hockey team with no defense, but lots of goal-scorers. They need to keep scoring and scoring until they have enough to win. That is sports.

So, I reject the idea that there is a magic number of statistics where the offense can feel free from evaluation. Quantity is fantasy football stuff. At the end of the day, do you have plenty of yards and points? Great. But, in real football, we have to ask about the points and yards you failed to gain because of execution or decisions. Why? Because if we lose games – regardless of score – everyone gets fired.

The name of the game is to win the game. And we need to ask everyone on the team if they could have given even more. And we know the answers. That is why we still do an offensive evaluation here every week in what we expect is the same way the actual team would do it.

Yes, the offense had some fancy numbers and yes, it ought to be enough. But, it wasn’t. And there were many points left out there. Some games, a baseball team needs to score 10 runs, even if 9 “ought to be enough”, it sometimes isn’t. So, why didn’t we get that runner home who was on 3rd with nobody out in the 5th?

It is ok to ask.

The Furious, Fall-Short Comebacks - A Cowboys Tradition​

We have seen more than a few offensive examples of this game over the years from the Cowboys of recent times. I have been doing this a long time to recall many of these from both the Romo and Prescott eras:

  • October 28, 2012 – New York Giants 29, Cowboys 24 - Trailed 23-0 early in the second quarter (multiple Romo interceptions, including a pick-six by Jason Pierre-Paul). Romo threw for a career-high 437 yards. Cowboys lost 29-24 after six turnovers. This was a classic “almost” from a deep hole.
  • November 22, 2012 - Washington Redskins 38, Cowboys 31 - The Redskins exploded for 28 points in the second quarter. Dallas trailed 28-3 at halftime. Late in the third quarter the Cowboys were still down 28-6. Romo then led a furious second-half rally. He finished with a career-high 441 yards and 3 TDs (including an 85-yard strike to Dez Bryant). Dallas scored 28 of the game’s final 41 points and cut the deficit to 35-28 with about eight minutes left.
  • January 15, 2017 – NFC Divisional Round Green Bay Packers 34, Cowboys 31 - Down 15, 28-13, late in the third quarter after Aaron Rodgers connected with Jared Cook. Dak Prescott and Ezekiel Elliott led 15 unanswered points in the fourth. Jason Witten caught a 6-yard TD (28-20), then Dez Bryant scored on a 7-yard pass with Prescott running in the 2-point conversion to tie it at 28 with 4 minutes left. Rodgers engineered a drive and hit Cook for 35 yards to set up Crosby’s walk-off 51-yard FG as time expired. Prescott finished 24-of-38 for 302 yards and 3 TDs; Elliott had 125 rushing yards.
  • January 14, 2024 - Wildcard Round - Green Bay Packers 48, Dallas 32 - Green Bay built a 27-0 lead late in the second quarter and led 48-16 early in the fourth quarter. Dallas did score some late points: two Dak Prescott touchdown passes to Jake Ferguson (with successful two-point conversions) in the final six minutes, cutting it to 48-32. Prescott finished 41-of-60 for 403 yards and 3 TDs.
  • September 22, 2024 - Baltimore Ravens 28, Dallas Cowboys 25 - The Ravens built a 28-6 lead by the end of the third quarter. In the fourth quarter the Cowboys staged a furious rally, scoring 19 unanswered points in roughly six minutes:

    They got within a field goal and still had time, but the Ravens converted a key third-and-6 and then Jackson ran for a first down after the two-minute warning to run out the clock. ⁠ Prescott finished 28-of-51 for 379 yards and 2 TDs. It was a classic “too little, too late” Cowboys comeback that fell just short.
  • November 15, 2026 – San Francisco 49ers 46, Cowboys 40 - down by 19 points in the fourth quarter, 38-19. Dak Prescott threw for 5 TDs (career high, 30-of-51 for 343 yards). George Pickens had a career-high 3 TDs. Cowboys scored 21 in the fourth, cutting it to 38-32. Then Prescott hit CeeDee Lamb for a 1-yard TD and ran in the 2-point conversion to make it 46-40 with 43 seconds left, as they fell short again.
Those were just six examples that come quickly to mind. In each of them, the Cowboys deserve credit for “fighting to the end” and never giving up. They also had incredible personal stats and had people saying “they did their part” quite often. But, in all six, we see Cowboys losses and key figures helped author their own defeat.

As Michael Jordan taught us, you can score 63 at the Boston Garden…and still lose. He said, “I’d much rather be scoreless and win the game than lose the game and score 63 points.”


Clearly on Sunday, the passing grades were everywhere for the offense:



The green is incredibly excellent and we saw plenty of really good things. Dak was under pressure a fair amount, but the OL held up and allowed only one sack and they also ran the ball fairly well when they tried to do so. Again, another downside of falling behind by three touchdowns is that the running game is eliminated by your own design.

The issue – as I continue to say – is that red box below. During this portion of the game, Dallas is out-scored 31-9. Now, the offense cannot do much about the 31, for sure. But, they can do two things that might modify things a bit.



  1. They can hold the ball much better. We see a 23-second possession and a 76-second possession there in the 2nd Quarter that both became punts.
  2. We saw two longer possessions in the 3rd Quarter, but totaled just 3 points when we can argue 14 points was needed. They left way too many points out there – and that started with the opening field goal.
To be the best, you have to beat the best. When you play San Francisco, everyone is going to have to play extraordinary football.

And that leaves us to today’s main thrust.

A Breakdown of the QB Performance​

Now, here at SturmStack, we are QB-friendly. Anyone who has followed my media career covering this team knows that I was a Tony Romo-apologist and then a Dak Prescott-apologist. Why? Well, the more you study the game, the more you know how impossible it is to play QB for this franchise. The bar of excellence and accomplishment is so high and the patience and forgiveness levels are so low. You are being compared to Roger Staubach and Troy Aikman constantly.

I do not make this a QB-only study each week, because I think there is too much of a tendency to always claim everything is the QB’s fault or credit. That is actually a very simplistic way to view this sport. Yet, I do try to grade Prescott’s plays every game on a play-by-play basis and I have to tell you that in this game, it was remarkable to me how many times he was trying to force things that weren’t there. A more patient approach that did not look rushed and anxious might have done the trick.

And that has been the theme against the 49ers during this frustrating 5-game cycle where he has never looked like himself. Here are those numbers over the series with SF since the 2021 playoff debacle.

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0439c949-2625-4ccc-8bcc-758aadd5c0f6_1386x98.png


The stat line was much better on Sunday, but the film does suggest that it took him a while to fully settle in and see the field. He played the 4th Quarter in a really excellent fashion, but if he started the game that way, I suggest Dallas is much more likely to win. Further, if he plays that way for 60 minutes, the 49ers offense doesn’t get 13 possessions to do damage because Dallas is choking the game away.

In other words, we just want to get to a game where Brock Purdy plays against Dak Prescott and we say that Dak was the better QB. In three regular season matchups, we have never seen it. Sunday is no exception.

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F42118b45-7a31-4eb2-95fe-c78f6bfe0a21_1374x328.png


And yes, even the one time they have met in the playoffs, a rookie Brock Purdy also out-played Dak.

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fa1dba1cd-6dd8-4575-9fef-5a4abf6b1ac9_1238x142.png


As you can see, Purdy has played Dallas four times and has never thrown a single interception. Dak Prescott has played San Francisco five times since 2021 and has never NOT thrown an interception. Nine picks to zero? A far better passer rating in every single meeting? Do we understand one key reason why one team keeps winning in the matchups?

Yes, I am a Dak Prescott apologist. But, I also cannot be unwilling to look at things honestly. I also recognize that it is easier being Brock Purdy where you have a great scheme, a great coach, and great teammates. No doubt.

But, it should also not be lost on anyone that Dak has chosen to stay here and knows who he works for. He has also chosen to get his maximum income, which nobody would blame him. But, as Don Draper might tell Peggy when people are blaming Dak and not blaming Cobie Durant as loudly, “that is what the money is for.”

Sometimes, it is ok to ask your $60m AAV QB to outplay the other QB in the game.

With that all in mind, we will be looking at the film study as if we are grading the QB. On Twitter, you will show a play and people get excited because you found one bad play and are unfairly demonstrating his day. I notated many examples of decisions and execution from QB1 today for my subscribers who know I don’t blame him recklessly or often.

But, today, I feel compelled to show you how a stat-line that looks this good could have been so much better.

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff1720e94-8fc4-42cd-bf78-7405fa0b8b86_1032x100.png


Let’s begin.

FILM STUDY​

1Q - 14:50 - 2-10-DAL 31 - D.Prescott pass incomplete short middle to C.Lamb.​


I imagine this play – just 10 seconds into the game – sticks with Dak quite a bit. This is a quick pitch and catch to CeeDee Lamb. I think it is pretty clear that there are zero safeties or DBs behind Lamb on this play. I am not suggesting a better throw goes for a 69-yard touchdown, but the throw is behind Lamb and goes incomplete. Could he put some loft on it to get it over Warner and set up a huge play? I think he wants that back.

1Q - 14:28 - 1-5-SF 49 - D.Prescott pass incomplete deep left to G.Pickens (R.Green) [K.White].​


His very next throw, it is 1st and 5. This is obviously a good idea to throw verticals up to George Pickens because there is a chance he can go get it and there is a chance he can draw a pass interference. But, I might say that if the plan is to take profits and to be methodical, I think we see how deep the LBs are dropping here and that Pickens never is close to open on this play. His corner is on top of him in Cover 3 the entire route and this is an incredibly hopeful idea. We obviously want to be aggressive and send a message, but if you pause the tape at the top of his drop, we see at least two underneath players that would easily get you a 1st down and the march continues with no worries. This is not a huge blunder, but why force the ball? This will be a theme.

1Q - 12:26 - 2-7-SF 34 - D.Prescott pass incomplete short right to C.Lamb (D.Lenoir).​


The 1st drive continues and this is a levels play to the right with Lamb and Flournoy. They will run this multiple times and both times, Dak misses a wide open Flournoy on the deep out and forces the ball to Lamb for an incompletion. The play is designed to put that outside corner in a conflict and the moment he steps to Lamb, Dak needs to see Flournoy uncovered behind him. There are misses and there are bad misses. This one is on Dak and he did it twice in this game. Flournoy is going to get you at least 20 yards here, but Prescott never even looked there. He was going to Lamb the moment the ball was snapped.

1Q - 12:21 - 3-7-SF 34 - D.Prescott pass incomplete short right to G.Pickens (D.Lenoir) [O.Odighizuwa].​


Here is the next play and this one is 3rd and 7 and the 49ers blitz. He has to get the ball out quickly so I won’t judge him too harshly, but I think Hunter Luepke is a much better look here than Pickens and I think he gets to the sticks. Giving Pickens a chance is fine, but this is a spot where I think we see enough misses here to suggest that taking three points to start the game is not ideal when there were a number of open options missed.

1Q - 1:56 - 3-1-SF 41 - J.Williams left tackle to SF 35 for 6 yards (R.Green, J.Thompson). FUMBLES (J.Thompson), and recovers at SF 35.​


3rd and 1 run here to Javonte Williams and I want to show CeeDee Lamb doing a great job here of getting involved. Williams does fumble here, but gets back on the ball to keep the drive alive.

1Q - 1:15 - 1-10-SF 35 - B.Jones reported in as eligible. D.Prescott pass deep right to G.Pickens for 35 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


We love 1st and 10 play-action with 12 personnel. Look at all of the space and all of the opportunity. Dak has time and sees that Pickens over the top with Lamb on the over-route provides great options. Prescott goes for the vertical shot and hits it nicely for a touchdown. Cowboys surge ahead, 10-7.

2Q - 14:50 - 3-4-DAL 32 - D.Prescott pass incomplete short middle to C.Lamb (M.Sigle).​


This is one of the quick 3 and outs early in the 2Q. I think this is great defense by the 49ers who have covered everything quite well. If I were to nitpick, I think Lamb has to sit down in this zone and stop running at the coverage. When you see Cover 6 on 3rd and 4, they will normally sit down here and move the chains. But, Dak leads him into a hit and that is not how you beat a zone in the middle very often.

2Q - 5:57 - 2-8-DAL 41 - D.Prescott pass incomplete short right to C.Lamb.​


Next possession and we have a 2nd and 8 at the Dallas 41. This is one of the plays where Nick Bosa makes a big impact and the 49ers almost get a gift from Prescott trying to force the ball into Lamb again. Dre Greenlaw bodies Lamb and has the ball hit him right in the hands. There were three turnover-worthy decisions by the QB in this game and this was definitely one of them. I like the route concept with Turpin looking like he might be a threat vertically, but Bosa ruined the play and the QB almost made it even worse.

2Q - 5:18 - 4-1-DAL 48 - H.Luepke up the middle to SF 43 for 9 yards (R.Green).​


Moments later, Dallas converts a 4th down with the FB dive going for 9 yards. Hunter Luepke busts through with some thunder and we like to see that. It keeps the drive alive and here comes the next touchdown.

2Q - 4:16 - 3-6-SF 39 - D.Prescott pass short left to G.Pickens for 39 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


For some reason, despite all of the success with zones, the 49ers do the Cowboys a favor here on 3rd and 6. They blitz with man coverage behind it. I’m sorry, but Pickens vs man coverage is always going to be a slant through the middle of the field and if the throw is on – it is – he is going to be a massive problem. Again, Lamb’s blocking is a credit to his desire to win and Pickens is having himself a big day. Great stuff.

2Q - 1:24 - 3-2-DAL 43 - D.Prescott pass incomplete deep middle to C.Lamb.​


Here is more of the forced ball issues to me. You need two yards on this 3rd and 2. You have Ryan Flournoy giving you a fresh set of downs easily right in front of your QB. And instead, we are trying to much more difficult deep shot to Lamb that isn’t close because you are trying to get it to him with pressure in your face and jumping as you throw. Now, there was also an offensive penalty here for an illegal formation, but the throw is missed so here comes the punt team again. Take the profit and move the chains. Forcing throws to your main guys is killing drives and costing points. Yes, they scored 40, but they should have had more than 16 at the half.

3Q - 8:48 - 3-6-SF 34 - D.Prescott pass incomplete deep right to G.Pickens (D.Lenoir).​


This play was a deep shot to Pickens that should have been a pass interference that went uncalled. But, again, at no point does Pickens have position to say this is a must throw. In fact, Lamb and Pickens have their corners still stacked on top of them vs Cover 3. You can definitely throw it, but your success probability is low due to the Niners sitting on this. But, if you pause the tape when Dak gets to the top of his drop, you see how deep the LBs are again. It is just 3rd and 6 and you just need the 28 yard line to extend the drive.

Using the player tracking below, when Dak is getting ready to make the throw, I see Luepke and Schoonmaker as opportunities to get the yellow line. It is just a matter of taking what the play presents rather than forcing the ball in hopeful heaves that leads you to settle for field goals. Nobody said the job was easy.



3Q - 3:49 - 3-2-SF 40 - D.Prescott pass incomplete short right to C.Lamb.​


Next drive. Huge moment. Does this look familiar? I guarantee the coaches ran this play again because Dak missed Flournoy on this play in the 1st Quarter (as we showed above). Would he do it again? Flournoy has to be biting his tongue. He is wide open. And, the forced ball to Lamb is bounced anyway. Just not great work from QB1 to this point of the game.

3Q - 3:46 - 4-2-SF 40 - D.Prescott pass deep right intended for C.Lamb INTERCEPTED by M.Mustapha [F.Warner] at SF 10. M.Mustapha to SF 10 for no gain (L.Schoonmaker)​


This is the very next play and the big one – the interception – at a point in the game where seven points is the only option. This is the spot in the game where you must make a play or the game gets away from you. It is pretty well protected and Dak has time. He rolls to his right. At the moment, you pause it at 0:20, he is thinking about running – but, I think Fred Warner probably causes quite a collision. Maybe he moves the chains, but I don’t like his odds. So, you have four places to potentially throw. Schoonmaker looks covered. Flournoy is actually coming free and it would be a great play, but we saw Brock Purdy make that a few times on Sunday. And then Pickens looks like a Touchdown over the top to the pylon. But, instead, it is a hopeful heave to Lamb that is not even close, into coverage, and picked off. Game over. They can call it an arm-punt all they want, but that, to me, is the game.

In the 4th Quarter, Dak would make some very nice plays that would obviously make the game interesting.

4Q - 10:00 - 1-10-SF 39 - D.Prescott pass deep right to C.Lamb pushed ob at SF 12 for 27 yards (M.Mustapha). P15 PENALTY on SF-M.Mustapha, Unnecessary Roughness, 6 yards, enforced at SF 12.​


This one to Lamb is really nice and confident and right in the turkey hole. Great throw and scored as one of his three big-time throws (along with the Pickens TD in the 1st Quarter).

4Q - 3:47 - 4-6-SF 11 - D.Prescott pass short left to R.Flournoy for 11 yards, TOUCHDOWN.​


And then here he is able to navigate the pocket and hit Flournoy nicely who came back to the ball.

Again, as the game went on, he seemed to slow down his process and find the open options with more calm and composure. But, early on, it was forced balls and at times, a little bit of panic.

So, on this day, I thought it was appropriate to show my math. He wasn’t bad at all. But, I don’t care if they scored 60 points. If you leave meat on the bone, it is ok to point it out.

To be clear, the defense is the reason this team is losing. But, to act like this offense and their most important player are playing to the best of their ability would be false. They did not score when they needed to, they did not possess the ball and control the game, they settled for field goals too often, and they were not nearly efficient enough.

They weren’t why they lost. But, they also weren’t why they won. They accumulated a lot of stats, but did not play as a winning offense on Sunday. That is my most objective and fair analysis I can offer.

Now, mercifully, let’s move on to Tennessee.
 
Back
Top Bottom