Sturm: Morning After Week 9 - Cowboys Just Can’t Do It The Easy Way

dpf1123

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
3,436

Morning After Week 9 - Cowboys Just Can’t Do It The Easy Way​

A loss would have been catastrophic, but the path to staying alive is available yet again.​

Bob Sturm
7 hours ago


If we have established anything for the 2026 Dallas Cowboys, it should be the following:

Winning is not easy. They have played nine games and have four wins – none of which are consecutive and most of which are not easy at all to secure. Sunday, in Indianapolis, they played a struggling team that is going nowhere. And yet, the Colts had the lead late in the fourth quarter.

The Cowboys had more than a few chances to end things earlier. They were incredibly close to perhaps getting their coach fired today. We said on Friday that this is the fork in the road on whether they planned on having even a competitive November or if our next coaching search and subsequent draft preparations could start immediately.

Thankfully, they chose victory. But, let’s not kid ourselves about the outcome and the current state of this team. Their path to victory on Sunday was filled with so many examples of the nonsense that plagues the team in 2026. They won the game, but did it in such an unsteady way that nobody will be willing to celebrate a substantial turning of a corner. They still seem to be their own worst enemy at times.

Let’s count the ways.


For me, this game started swerving late in the 3rd Quarter. Until then, everything had gone reasonably well as Dallas had held the Colts to just 79 1st half yards against 226 of their own. They were up 17-7 at the half after a fantastic drive to end the first 30 minutes when Dak Prescott shook off a very poor start and began hitting CeeDee Lamb in that way that we have come to expect. Back to back plays before halftime that went for 22 yards on third down and then 44 yards for a touchdown in the final minute put the Cowboys up double-digits on a hapless opponent heading into the locker-room. Everything looked like we had hoped it would look.

The third quarter began with Caleb Downs and Quinnen Williams both thwarting more aggressive Colts offensive ideas in back to back drives. This will be a theme today as the two best talents on this defense would both put substantial fingerprints all over this victory. Caleb and Quinnen would repeatedly make plays and in the 3rd Quarter, they were front and center as the stadium started to once again lose patience with their frustrating home side.

The Colts did manage a field goal on that second third-quarter drive, so Dallas would lead 17-10 as they regained the ball and as our story of how the Cowboys just can’t do anything the easy way would truly begin.

On 1st and 10 from the Colts 11 with 3:04 left in the third quarter, Prescott sees Lamb in man coverage against Sauce Gardner as the Colts send a six-man pressure blitz. Dak loves this opportunity because all he has to do is drop the pass right in the bucket and its a wrap. There is nothing Sauce can do against a perfect pass. Dak delivers it with the ideal spacing to allow Lamb to get his feet in bounds. For reasons, we cannot quite comprehend, Lamb gets a bit casual with his left foot and instead of tapping a toe, he just steps right out of bounds. Obviously, he is one of the very best receivers on Planet Earth, so we will relax about the charges here, but this is a case where CeeDee is much better than he shows here.


Instead of up 24-10, Dallas must settle for only going up 20-10 as the rest of the sequence ends in a field goal. This will be their first self-inflicted error, but there will be many more.

Roughly a minute later, the Colts show us why you cannot waste touchdowns in this league. Brandon Aubrey gives them amazing field position with another mistake and penalty on his kickoff and then on the 2nd play of the possession, the Colts score a touchdown on a quick little bubble screen to Ashton Dulin. The design of the play is to make PJ Locke tackle in space and I think we now have about a half-dozen examples of this in the last few weeks where he is a massive liability in this department. Instead of a tackle, he wipes out his help and Dulin is off to the races for a 55-yard Touchdown on a pass that traveled 0 yards downfield.

Incredibly, without any sustained offense, the Colts have now closed the gap to 20-17.

But, obviously, the Cowboys have more weapons and the response will be in short order.

Instead, Lamb is called for an offensive pass interference on 3rd and 2 from nearly midfield. Back it up 10 yards and it will be 3rd and 12.

This time, it is a seven-man blitz with Cover 0 behind it. Dak is going to have three rushers in his lap, but his throw allows Lamb to convert the 3rd and long and then get back up and run when he is untouched by his man, Kenneth Harris. So, he does and runs from the 38 down to the 14, at which point the ball comes out when his hand hits the ground. Initially, it appears the ground caused the fumble, but due to being untouched, the Colts challenged the play and were given the recovery. Again, CeeDee has a huge account full of credibility, but this is his 2nd “own-goal” late in this game that is making victory much more difficult to secure than anyone would like. He has now personally cost Dallas roughly a full touchdown on just these two mistakes. Given that they still only lead by 3, that will prove to be a big deal.

But, wait, there is much more.

Daron Bland gets back in the self-inflicted errors game by committing a 40-yard pass interference play when he gets beaten and then turned around on a deep ball from Daniel Jones to rookie and Sooner Deion Burks. Burks is yet another speedy receiver who Bland just cannot keep up with and flips the field at just the wrong moment. This seems to be a weekly occasion for the Cowboys most highly compensated defensive back.

Dee Winters is then called for a rather dubious Unnecessary Roughness call on Dulin and the Colts are very much in business to take the lead.

But, on the very next play, Quinnen Williams again takes over and meets Jonathan Taylor in the backfield. Not only does he ring up another tackle for loss, but this time he takes the ball away, too. Shemar James will recover the fumble and the Cowboys may have dodged a bullet with a huge takeaway.

Except, that there is a man in “blue sweats and a stocking cap” who ran on to the field to celebrate with his mates. Yes, it is DeMarvion Overshown, who is inactive on this day but still helps the Cowboys commit yet another own-goal mistake late in a close game that they cannot afford to lose.

Personal foul on a guy not even playing today.


It seemed a perfect example of the Cowboys needing a bit more of a disciplinarian as their leader and reminds us of Rashan Gary’s brain-dead head-butt of Gardner Minshew last week after the ball was gone to demonstrate how details matter in this league where every game is as close as it can possibly be at all times.

Dallas will lose 15 yards and then punt, which sets up rookie RB Seth McGowan for the longest run of his career at 7:43 in the 4th in which PJ Locke shows us yet again that he cannot tackle in space – and also can take out his teammate in the process. That will earn the Colts the game-tying field goal with 6:01 to go. We are locked at 20-20 and it is anyone’s ball-game.

So, Dak and CeeDee go right back to work. Even when they stop themselves, they still seem to have the ability to dip into their bag anytime they need it. No George Pickens on this day hardly bothered them at all. Prescott threw to Lamb 16 times and they collected 195 yards, a touchdown, and as we documented earlier, they left plenty of meat on the bone. But, not this time as 31-yards put them right back in a spot to take the lead.


They make it look so easy and a few moments later, they ask Brandon Aubrey to go do what he is tasked to do as the NFL’s all-time highest paid kicker at $7 million a year and $20 million in fully guaranteed money.

And, of course, he misses it. Not just by a little, either. He missed it by plenty to the left. It reminds us that he hasn’t been all that great in the last two seasons, to be honest.

Brandon Aubrey is now 14/24 on 50+ yard field goals since the beginning of last season. 58% hit rate is the second-worst among all kickers with 15+ 50-yard attempts. Only Harrison Butker (44%) has been worse.
So, again, with 3:30 to go, the Cowboys appear likely to lose a game they have no business losing. Have I listed eight mistakes? Nine?

Because of the missed field goal, the Colts don’t need to do much to get into their own FG range to make a winner. A few 1st downs is all it takes and they do just that before they hit a 50-yard field goal of their own and the Colts lead with 1:41 to go, 23-20.

What happened next – on the first play of a must-score drive – was a piece of true brilliance by Ryan Flournoy.


Now, look, we criticize the Cowboys plenty and they deserve much of it. But, the team signed Flournoy on a 1-year extension ($4.5 million) for 2027 back on September 11 and the gamble was that he might be their WR2 next season for George Pickens. The growth in his game has been exceptional and he seems to be ready. But, to make this catch and this moment against Sauce Gardner and with only one arm free is just insane.

Prescott lets this bomb go from about his own 27-yard line and it drops from the sky about 50-yards later down the field. Flournoy does not have his left arm available because Sauce is holding it, so he pins the ball at that distance against his chest and secures the ball which ultimately will help secure a win. Let us never get so cynical about this team that we don’t appreciate the degree of difficulty and accomplishment that single play is at that point of a game that might end the season and the coach’s career. That was simply ridiculous.

They will score a touchdown a few moments later (and a few Colts flags later) to take the 27-23 lead.

And then, with the game on the line, Caleb Downs finishes it with his first career interception. He had a sack, an interception, and two more passes defended in this game and it seemed to be the finest game of his NFL career so far. In fact, he was the first Cowboys defender to have a sack and an interception in the same game since Week 1 of 2024 (Erik Kendricks in Cleveland) and nobody else had done it since DeMarcus Lawrence in 2021.

The last Cowboys rookie to do it? If you know this one, you have either heard it this morning or are a complete psycho: The last Cowboys rookie with a sack and interception in the same game was Tommy Haynes in 1987 - a lockout replacement player who played just three games – and did it twice!

https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F958dc755-9000-499f-8658-6718427f0b2f_1196x260.png


In other words, Caleb Downs has pretty much done something yesterday that no actual Dallas Cowboys player has ever done other than Bill Bates in 1983.

So, in summary, Quinnen Williams is fantastic, Caleb Downs is a great rookie, and Dallas kept their season alive by winning a very ugly game.

But, guess what, there is no such thing as an ugly victory in this league. Every win is beautiful and counts the same.

Because of it, they have a chance now to revive their season with a showdown game against San Francisco at home next Sunday. That will be the stiffest test they get all year, we’d imagine, so this mirage may not last long.

But, I promise you, firing a coach today would not have given even a glimmer of hope. Winning beats losing every single time. Let’s see if they can actually string two of these together. If they can, 2026 might actually be back on.
 
Prescott lets this bomb go from about his own 27-yard line and it drops from the sky about 50-yards later down the field. Flournoy does not have his left arm available because Sauce is holding it, so he pins the ball at that distance against his chest and secures the ball which ultimately will help secure a win. Let us never get so cynical about this team that we don’t appreciate the degree of difficulty and accomplishment that single play is at that point of a game that might end the season and the coach’s career. That was simply ridiculous.
Definitely not a number 2, though.
 
Firing Schottenheimer would be a massive glimmer of hope, just not for this season which is basically lost anyway.
 
Firing Schottenheimer would be a massive glimmer of hope, just not for this season which is basically lost anyway.

They aren't firing Schotty during the season. But I guess a Garrett just enough wins to keep his job would be pretty bad.
 
Back
Top Bottom