Speaking of being irrational, only an irrational hater could have someone tell them "Yes, you are right for the most part" and then spend the next ten pages demanding that they receive 100% compliance OR ELSE! GRRR
It's why the Nodaks and Iamtdgs of the world have no more credibility on this matter than they accuse me of having.
SAY GARRETT SUCKS OR ELSE!! SAY IT!!!!
Yeah, for the most part, Wade is more skilled as an X's and O's tactician. However, when his goofball persona leads a team to tune him out, he's utterly ineffective and he sucks as a coordinator. Given that this happens every 3-4 years or so with him, you have to factor that into your evaluation. Additionally, it's not as if Garrett is completely unskilled as a tactician despite what you'd hear on this board. He'd win a few in a head-to-head against Wade in that contest.
Sorry that the complicated facts come off as "spin" to those who have no tolerance for divergence from their tired old song and dance about Garrett being a dummy.