One SB lightning in bottle fluke, sure, but QBs with multiple SB appearances is a surprisingly pretty consistent gauge with the greatest modern QBs of all-time. I wouldn’t use SB appearances as my one and only factor, but looking at the list off top of my head, it’s not too shabby. Maybe it’s more cause and effect, chicken or egg?
What QBs considered greatest all time conversations had one or less SB appearances. Probably Young, Marino, Rodgers and Brees are only exceptions. Not too bad.
Brady, Bradshaw, Montana, Elway, Staubach, Aikman, Favre, Peyton Manning, Warner, Starr, Tarkenton, etc. all had multiple.
QBs with multiple SB appearances probably shows better than career QB Rating or QBs with most passing yards.
On flip side, Plunkett, Russell, Wilson and Eli are probably only multiple SB quarterbacks that don’t belong anywhere on a Top 10 all-time list.