Machota: Cowboys positional review - How will Mike McCarthy utilize Ezekiel Elliott?

Cotton

One-armed Knife Sharpener
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
120,368
By Jon Machota 43m ago

With the start of NFL free agency a little over a week away and the draft less than two months down the road, we’re taking a look at the Cowboys roster to see where it has depth and where it will need help in the near future.

The third item in our nine-part series focuses on the running back position.

How they performed in 2019:

Considering that the Cowboys were fresh off making Ezekiel Elliott the NFL’s highest-paid running back, expectations were very high for the position. Add in the return of Travis Frederick at center, another Day 2 draft pick spent on an offensive lineman in Connor McGovern and a fourth-round pick used on running back Tony Pollard, and this had the ability to be the league’s best rushing attack.

However, the Ravens, 49ers, Titans and Seahawks all averaged more yards per game than the Cowboys’ 134.6. The Ravens, Cardinals and Titans averaged more yards per carry than Dallas’ 4.8.

In Elliott’s first season playing all 16 games, he finished fourth in rushing at 1,357 yards. He won the rushing title in 2016 (1,631 yards) and 2018 (1,434 yards) while playing 15 games in each.

The biggest difference for Elliott in Year 4 was an absence of explosive runs. He had 14 rushing attempts go for 20 or more yards in 2016 and 11 in 2018. Last season, he only managed four. Elliott had three runs of 40 or more yards during his rookie year and one in 2018. He didn’t come up with a single run of 40 yards or more last season.

Elliott scored 14 touchdowns in 2019 (12 rushing, 2 receiving), which tied him for fifth-most in the NFL, trailing only Green Bay’s Aaron Jones (19), Carolina’s Christian McCaffrey (19), Tennessee’s Derrick Henry (18) and Baltimore’s Mark Ingram (15).

Pollard finished his rookie season with 455 rushing yards and two touchdowns. Both scores and over half of his total yards came in two games, wins over the Dolphins and Rams. Despite being an outstanding receiver in college, Pollard only caught 15 passes for 107 yards and one touchdown during his rookie season.

Bottom line: The Cowboys needed more out of their running game in 2019, particularly on the road when the passing game wasn’t having much success. In losses at New Orleans, New England, Chicago and Philadelphia, Dallas averaged just 72.5 yards per game on the ground. While those were all top-10 run defenses, better results are expected with all of the investments the Cowboys have made in their running game over the years. Running the ball better in at least one of those games would’ve led to a playoff berth.

The future:

The biggest question in regards to the Cowboys’ rushing attack entering this season is this: How will new head coach Mike McCarthy utilize the most talented running back he’s ever had?

While in Green Bay, McCarthy’s top backs were Ahman Green at the end of his career, Ryan Grant and Eddie Lacy. Elliott is a more complete and more talented player than any of those three.

McCarthy’s West Coast offenses have been focused on making quarterbacks like Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers successful. Since becoming Cowboys head coach, McCarthy has stressed that Elliott and the running game will be a significant part of his plan to make QB Dak Prescott successful.

“Making a quarterback successful, I think, is really common sense,” McCarthy said two weeks ago. “It’s really part of the bylaws and how the West Coast offense was designed. So that’s what I’ll always believe in because he touches the ball every play. He’s the player that’s going to have the ball in his hands at the most critical part of the game in the fourth quarter. As far as your playmakers, you’ve got five premier positions. Obviously, running back is one of them.

“You get the ball to your playmaker. Zeke will touch the football plenty in our offense. When I say, ‘It’s all about the quarterback,’ it’s not taking away (from Elliott). Someone has to give the ball to the playmaker. So it makes sense to develop that way. Zeke will be a primary focus for us offensively.”

McCarthy and second-year offensive coordinator Kellen Moore will be tasked with not only keeping Elliott heavily involved but finding ways to get Pollard more opportunities.

As long as Elliott is healthy, he’ll get the bulk of the running back touches. Pollard brings a different dimension to the position, though, which has many wanting to see more plays designed with both on the field at the same time. Moore seems open to that idea, but it will depend on what McCarthy’s plans are after free agency and the draft.

During McCarthy’s 13 seasons as Green Bay’s head coach (2006 to 2018), the Packers were never in the top 10 in rushing attempts. Green Bay’s average under McCarthy was 413 carries per season, including a league-low 333 during his final season.

To compare, since Elliott was drafted by the Cowboys in 2016, Dallas has averaged 467 rushing attempts per season, including 499 in 2016.

The expectations are that McCarthy will run a little more than he did in Green Bay because of the roster he inherited, but it’s unlikely he’ll run as much as Jason Garrett’s teams did from 2014 with DeMarco Murray to 2019 with Elliott.

How things could change this offseason:

Having a three-time Pro Bowler in Elliott and a talented backup in Pollard makes this one of the deepest positions on the roster. No significant changes are expected. Those two will see the bulk of the workload. Elliott is under contract through the 2026 season, having signed a six-year, $90 million contract last year. He should be around through the 2022 season at the very least; even if he declines significantly, the cap penalty for moving on from him would be too significant to part ways until then. Pollard is signed through 2022.

The only notable change that could come is at fullback. McCarthy has always had fullbacks on his rosters. The Cowboys have a team option on Jamize Olawale. If McCarthy is looking for a different type of fullback, perhaps the Cowboys go in a different direction at the position in free agency or via trade.
 

UncleMilti

This seemed like a good idea at the time.
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
18,005
Why would he have needed to run the ball when he had an all timer at QB?

Dak will never be an all timer, and the Cowboys brain trust has a mentality that’s stuck in the 90s when you needed a premier RB to be successful. Hence, Dallas spending a premium pick on a RB when the new era NFL has multiple SB and playoff teams who got there with RBs picked in the later rounds. I like Elliott but he’s not getting us to a SB, and his declining production is scary.

Now McCarthy comes in and will need to modify his WC offense to use Elliott, because of the huge resources put into that pick. And, because Jerry said so.
 

L.T. Fan

I'm Easy If You Are
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
21,703
Why would he have needed to run the ball when he had an all timer at QB?

Dak will never be an all timer, and the Cowboys brain trust has a mentality that’s stuck in the 90s when you needed a premier RB to be successful. Hence, Dallas spending a premium pick on a RB when the new era NFL has multiple SB and playoff teams who got there with RBs picked in the later rounds. I like Elliott but he’s not getting us to a SB, and his declining production is scary.

Now McCarthy comes in and will need to modify his WC offense to use Elliott, because of the huge resources put into that pick. And, because Jerry said so.
Yep. Elliot fizzled pretty fast. The conversations about him contending for best Cowboy ever running back can go to the back burner for a while.
 

NoDak

Hotlinking' sonofabitch
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,316
Damn. Just how smoking hot do you have to be If 1357 yds, 4.5 yds per, 12 TDs, 54 rec is “fizzled pretty fast.”

Yeah, he was down a little from his previous standard. But people are carrying on like he had a shit year and is done. Laughable at best.
 

L.T. Fan

I'm Easy If You Are
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
21,703
Damn. Just how smoking hot do you have to be If 1357 yds, 4.5 yds per, 12 TDs, 54 rec is “fizzled pretty fast.”

Yeah, he was down a little from his previous standard. But people are carrying on like he had a shit year and is done. Laughable at best.
His attitude of holding out and making demands while he still had nearly two years to go on his existing contract soured some of us on his demeanor.
 

NoDak

Hotlinking' sonofabitch
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,316
His attitude of holding out and making demands while he still had nearly two years to go on his existing contract soured some of us on his demeanor.
And? That doesn't have a single thing to do with your original statement in regards to his play on the field and/or his contending for best ever Cowboys running back. Those were statements in regards to his talent and production. Now you're talking about attitude? Two different things.
 

data

Forbes #1
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
50,478
And? That doesn't have a single thing to do with your original statement in regards to his play on the field and/or his contending for best ever Cowboys running back. Those were statements in regards to his talent and production. Now you're talking about attitude? Two different things.
Reminds me of Juror #3 in 12 Angry Men.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,239
Why would he have needed to run the ball when he had an all timer at QB?

Dak will never be an all timer, and the Cowboys brain trust has a mentality that’s stuck in the 90s when you needed a premier RB to be successful. Hence, Dallas spending a premium pick on a RB when the new era NFL has multiple SB and playoff teams who got there with RBs picked in the later rounds. I like Elliott but he’s not getting us to a SB, and his declining production is scary.

Now McCarthy comes in and will need to modify his WC offense to use Elliott, because of the huge resources put into that pick. And, because Jerry said so.
Well I hope he uses him because he’s a dangerous weapon and not like the blunt hammer Garrett always treated him as.

Garrett barely used Elliott in the passing game despite some of the greatest plays we’ve ever seen from Zeke coming as a pass catcher.

Nope, Garrett was Mr. Checkdown.

What? Zeke scored a TD on a screen play? Ok, let’s never run that again.
 

UncleMilti

This seemed like a good idea at the time.
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
18,005
His attitude of holding out and making demands while he still had nearly two years to go on his existing contract soured some of us on his demeanor.
1600 yards, to 900 yards, 1400 yards to 1300 yards along with longest runs of 83, to 72, to 38 to 27. The suspension messed everything up, so the 900 yards is an outlier, but the yards are going down with relatively the same carries.

He isn't washed up but anyone arguing that he isn't declining in production is full of shit. Is it him, or is it something else? Well, we will find out this season.
 

UncleMilti

This seemed like a good idea at the time.
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
18,005
Well I hope he uses him because he’s a dangerous weapon and not like the blunt hammer Garrett always treated him as.

Garrett barely used Elliott in the passing game despite some of the greatest plays we’ve ever seen from Zeke coming as a pass catcher.

Nope, Garrett was Mr. Checkdown.

What? Zeke scored a TD on a screen play? Ok, let’s never run that again.
I agree. I just don't see the explosiveness in Elliott anymore, but he definitely is a good receiver out of the backfield.
 

jsmith6919

Honored Member - RIP
Joined
Aug 26, 2013
Messages
28,407
but he definitely is a good receiver out of the backfield.
FFS that was one of the big selling points for taking Zeke at 4th overall was he was a complete 3 down back. Then gingerfuck reverted to wanting a separate 3rd down rb damn near immediately
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,239
He’s only human and they were wise to draft Pollard, sign Cobb, and open up the passing game.

He can’t continue to be the focal point of the offense. I’d like to see him used more like Marshall Faulk was in St. Louis vs. run-first, lead battering ram.

For this to happen you have to be a pass-first team. That’s not the same as a pass-more team.

You need to force good teams out of 8-man fronts and the only way that happens is to win 1-1 coverage battles and throw to players who look covered.
 

L.T. Fan

I'm Easy If You Are
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
21,703
Well I hope he uses him because he’s a dangerous weapon and not like the blunt hammer Garrett always treated him as.

Garrett barely used Elliott in the passing game despite some of the greatest plays we’ve ever seen from Zeke coming as a pass catcher.

Nope, Garrett was Mr. Checkdown.

What? Zeke scored a TD on a screen play? Ok, let’s never run that again.
Yes the screen to Elliot was attempted a few more times and it didn’t work. The throw was off or Elliot was tackled immediately after the catch. Regardless it was pretty much good for one play and most probably was defended when Elliot was on the field in an obvious passing play. This is based on what I remember.
 

Cowboysrock55

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
53,208
FFS that was one of the big selling points for taking Zeke at 4th overall was he was a complete 3 down back. Then gingerfuck reverted to wanting a separate 3rd down rb damn near immediately
I don't think he is that great of a recieving back anymore. He isn't shifty enough to get great seperation in his routes and most of his catches just sort of stop and die.

Screens are totally different. Love Zeke for a screen and I'd still use him occasionally on a wheel route where he can get his speed up. But most of the receiving stuff Pollard is way better at.
 

Cotton

One-armed Knife Sharpener
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
120,368
But most of the receiving stuff Pollard is way better at.
This is the one big hope with McCarthy. He has already stated that he wants them on the field at the same time. Hopefully, this means getting Pollard more touches in the passing and running games.
 
  • Props
Reactions: p1_

UncleMilti

This seemed like a good idea at the time.
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
18,005
Emmitt "declined" some seasons, too.

OH NO! :panic
After 6 years in and 3 SB's later. OH NO!

Hell, 10 years in, Emmitt was still ripping off 40-60 yard runs- and no one would ever confuse Emmitt for a fast back. Emmitts "decline" and Elliotts decline aren't even in the same zipcode.

We could only be so lucky to see the kind of production and heart out of Elliott that we had in Emmitt.
 
Last edited:

NoDak

Hotlinking' sonofabitch
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,316
After 6 years in and 3 SB's later. OH NO!
:lol
Check the stats and try again. They didn't go up every year. Some years they ~GASP~ went down. And that was in the first 6 years, as you mentioned here. In fact, from year 3 to 4 he fell almost 3 hundred yards. The friggin bum.
 

L.T. Fan

I'm Easy If You Are
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
21,703
:lol
Check the stats and try again. They didn't go up every year. Some years they ~GASP~ went down. And that was in the first 6 years, as you mentioned here. In fact, from year 3 to 4 he fell almost 3 hundred yards. The friggin bum.
No one is trashing Elliot but I think some feel as I do. After threatening a hold out and creating a circumstance two seasons before his contract ran which altered the dynamics of getting other needed players signed, we expected his production to be commencement to what he was paid. Maybe our expectations are too high but so is the contract he received. That is why we think this season is to be a show and tell experience got him.
 

Rev

Good, bad, I'm the guy with the gun
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
19,673
No one is trashing Elliot but I think some feel as I do. After threatening a hold out and creating a circumstance two seasons before his contract ran which altered the dynamics of getting other needed players signed, we expected his production to be commencement to what he was paid. Maybe our expectations are too high but so is the contract he received. That is why we think this season is to be a show and tell experience got him.
That happens with almost every single player in every sport. They get a big contract and then numbers arent the same as the "contract year". I know his situation was a little different but its not unique either.
 
Top Bottom