Point/Counterpoint: What should we do with our first pick?

Carp said:
Beckham, Ellington, Huff, Gallon...those guys interest me most. Archer just on pure speed, but I don't honestly know much about him except that he is fast.
Click to expand...

Archer is like McCluster. Not really a WR.
 
I have a real mancrush on Ellington and he won't cost a first.
 
All in all, Evans won't be around at our pick anyways, so this is a pointless debate.
 
Carp said:
Cooks I like too, but I think he and Beckham may go in the first and I don’t want to do that.
Click to expand...

I'd be very surprised if either makes it out of the first. I think both of their 40 times locked up their spots in the first round. Cooks especially.
 
Gallon is underrated...he had shitty QBs at Mich, but I think he is on par with Ellington and would be a lower pick. These types have big value now...McCluster is an example of that.
 
Dez Bryant is a playmaker who transcends being just a #1 WR. He has the potential to be a ROH/HOF kind of player. Having two of him would be amazing.

While booze is right that you generally seek complementary styles, a chance to get Bryant's kind of talent couldn't be passed up.
 
ravidubey said:
Dez Bryant is a playmaker who transcends being just a #1 WR. He has the potential to be a ROH/HOF kind of player. Having two of him would be amazing.

While booze is right that you generally seek complementary styles, a chance to get Bryant's kind of talent couldn't be passed up.
Click to expand...

Correct. You'd need four defenders just against those two WRs. Great mismatch in our favor.

If he's not there, I'm certainly ok looking for a guy like Ellington or Huff later.
 
mschmidt64 said:
Correct. You'd need four defenders just against those two WRs. Great mismatch in our favor.
Click to expand...

If we had a head coach or OC like Sean Payton that could work. Garrett wouldn't know how to use them because he doesn't know how to adjust his playbook.
 
Clay_Allison said:
If we had a head coach or OC like Sean Payton that could work. Garrett wouldn't know how to use them because he doesn't know how to adjust his playbook.
Click to expand...

You shouldn't draft for Garrett's limitations since he'd be replaced as soon as an elite head coach comes available.

It's why the GM should be separate from the coach.

You get the next guy in here and maybe he can do wonders with two WRs like that.
 
mschmidt64 said:
You shouldn't draft for Garrett's limitations since he'd be replaced as soon as an elite head coach comes available.

It's why the GM should be separate from the coach.

You get the next guy in here and maybe he can do wonders with two WRs like that.
Click to expand...

Probably not since the only thing that can get Garrett fired is a season where Romo is too hurt to carry his bullshit offense to "entertaining" levels of mediocrity. Then we'll have Brandon Weeden throwing to those guys.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom