data
Forbes #1
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2013
- Messages
- 50,380
Out of all the goat lists produced by respected publications and ppl, I agree with this random youtuber’s list the most. Others tend to have explanations/justifications that I wildly scoff at, but this guy is quite agreeable in how he weighs postseason vs regular, peak vs longevity, supporting cast, and era/stats.
Note, his QB list is right before the Super Bowl regarding Mahomes.
Biggest disagreement is his RB list. He mentions postseason performance for QBs and WRs, but doesn’t mention it once for RBs. As a result, he has Emmitt Smith lower than I would and probably much lower than many of you. This major fail aside, commendable three lists overall.
I would’ve liked him to acknowledge that Staubach lost 4-6 prime years of accumulating career stats and Super Bowl appearances that would’ve propelled him higher in this list.
Note, his QB list is right before the Super Bowl regarding Mahomes.
Biggest disagreement is his RB list. He mentions postseason performance for QBs and WRs, but doesn’t mention it once for RBs. As a result, he has Emmitt Smith lower than I would and probably much lower than many of you. This major fail aside, commendable three lists overall.
I would’ve liked him to acknowledge that Staubach lost 4-6 prime years of accumulating career stats and Super Bowl appearances that would’ve propelled him higher in this list.
Last edited: