Smitty
DCC 4Life
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2013
- Messages
- 22,561
I strongly disagree.We overrate the negative effects of coaching in Dallas.
In 11 years, Lewis has been to the playoffs 4 times and never won a playoff game. I mean, I guess going 9-7 or 10-6 is "better" but to me, given that it's not with the negative weight of Jerry, I don't see a tangible difference. Lewis also has a couple of 4-12s in there and plenty of 8-8s and 7-9s.Just like you underrate the negative effects of the coaching scenarios some of these guys took over. Marvin Lewis has had multiple nice seasons in Cincinnati. The one city that is basically a Dallas clone in terms of horrible managment. Schwartz took over an 0-16 team and built them into multiple playoff teams, including 2 games where he outcoached Garrett to stunning come from behind victories.
I see absolutely no difference between him and Kubiak or Schwartz. You have to rank those guys, right, but if one is 15, one is 16, and one is 17, then I'm saying that's all really just a tie for 15.
I think Garrett is similarly placed. It's all more or less the same in that range.