BTB: If You Could Have One Player From Each NFC East Team ...

[Clay_Allison]

I would take Nicks before I'd take Cruz.

either or, their numbers are very similar.

 

[Smitty]

either or, their numbers are very similar.

Cruz drops to many important passes. I think he's a product of his relationship with Manning.

Not saying he's not good... just that he's not Pro Bowler good. I actually think Nicks is not Manning's favorite option there and he might do better elsewhere. Which is kinda irrelevant because he'd be #2 here as well, but in terms of raw talent, I think Nicks is the clear but better big play WR.

 

[Playmaker]

Manning, Griffin and Maclin. I'll trade Maning & Griffin for whatever and the giants & skins are starting over without qb's.

 

[NoDak]

Giants - Victor Cruz. Outside of Cruz, the rest have injury concerns, and Dallas needs more team speed.
Redskins - Alfred Morris. Solidify the damned running game. Trent Williams works too. I feel the performances of both have been artificially bolstered by the read-option.
Eagles - Evan Mathis or LeSean McCoy.

Morris and McCoy? You gonna run the wishbone?

I'd take Trent Williams, Fletcher Cox, and Chris Snee.