Instead of focusing on who's better, I prefer to discuss which environment maximized and best suited each QBs skill set and, conversely,which environment wouldve been most detrimental.
is Aikman better in the Norv Turner offense as he was, or would he have been better/worse in Garrett's offense highly reliant on the QB making pre snap audibles, check downs and protection scheme changes, while operating out of the shotgun?
would Romo the gunslinger be happy with Turner's timing based offense that was more methodical, or would romo lose patience and go rogue with more deep shots?