MacMahon: No joke - Jerry Jones deserves credit

Cotton

One-armed Knife Sharpener
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
120,030
No joke: Jerry Jones deserves credit
December, 21, 2014

By Tim MacMahon | ESPNDallas.com

ARLINGTON, Texas -- Sometimes the Jerry Jones jokes are just so easy.

Case in point: Remember when his Dallas Cowboys sent playoff tickets to their season-ticket holders this summer, something never before done in the NFL?

That resulted in plentiful punchlines for a franchise that was in the midst a four-year playoff drought, the longest of Jones' ownership tenure that started in 1989. It seemed to provide further proof that the Cowboys' owner is a marketing genius but their general manager a football fool.

So many times over the Past 17 years -- a span that features only one playoff win -- Cowboys fans have lamented that the businessman owner believed he was a wise enough football man to also run the team as a general manager.

Well, those fans can activate the barcodes on the tickets they were sent this summer. GM Jerry's Cowboys are the NFC East champions, punching their playoff tickets with a 42-7 pounding Sunday of the Indianapolis Colts.

Time to put all the Jerry jokes on hold, huh? Relax on ripping the most harshly criticized general manager in sports history.

"First of all, I'd like for you to think about that on Christmas,” Jones said while celebrating his franchise's biggest win, joking about being the subject of so much scorn and ridicule. "Think about these matters for your fellow man.”

Seriously, while a man with skin like an armadillo shell doesn't let the criticism get to him, Jones deserves his share of the credit for the Cowboys' success.

Start with a couple of Jones' most criticized decisions over the past few years, each of which has played a significant role in the 11-4 Cowboys' success this season.

How many talking heads and sports radio hosts have hollered about Jones being a sentimental sucker for giving a veteran quarterback with one playoff victory a six-year, $108 million extension with $55 million guaranteed? Anyone have a problem with Tony Romo's contact at this point?

In a week when $127 million quarterback Jay Cutler watched from the Chicago Bears' bench, Romo completed 18 of 20 passes for 218 yards and four touchdowns in a near-flawless performance against the Colts. As a result, Romo ranks atop the NFL's passer rating leaders, and the Cowboys are legitimately lobbying for him to be considered as an MVP candidate.

That's money well spent.

How many times have fans and media tried to fire head coach Jason Garrett over the past few 8-8 seasons? Jones shut out the noise, sticking with an inexperienced coach he was convinced had the potential to be one of the best in the business.

Considering that most saw 8-8 as an optimistic prediction for the Cowboys this season, Garrett must be included as a Coach of the Year candidate. There's no question that Garrett, who is in the final year of his contract, will coach the Cowboys for the foreseeable future.

Garrett has proven his patient boss right.

Critics can point out that Jones had to be talked into a lot of the Cowboys' front office's smartest decisions in recent years.

Take the rebuilding of an offensive line now widely considered the best in the NFL, for instance. Jones had never drafted an offensive lineman in the first round until Garrett convinced him to take tackle Tyron Smith in 2011. The Cowboys took Travis Frederick after trading down in the first round last year -- and were laughed at for doing so, but Dallas' scouts had the center ranked much higher than most. And owner Jerry admittedly wanted to draft glitzy quarterback Johnny Manziel in the first round this year, but he went with the consensus of the draft room and took a boring guard, Zack Martin.

Smith, Frederick and Martin should all be Pro Bowl selections this season, having played huge roles in the Cowboys' league-best rushing attack. And Jerry should be applauded for listening to the football men around him, such as his son and director of player personnel Stephen Jones, assistant director of player personnel Will McClay, Garrett and the team's scouts.

Good general managers hire smart people and trust them. That's what Jones has done lately.

The Cowboys have had their fair share of personnel misses lately, too, which gives them something in common with every other NFL team. But Jones certainly isn't above being second-guessed all of the sudden.

As a matter of fact, it happens almost every morning when he looks in the mirror.

"I really can't tell you I haven't looked back on decisions,” Jones said. "Do I second-guess them? Yes, I do. I sure do. I spend too much time second-guessing decisions. I don't know if I could be an effective play-to-play quarterback because I think a lot about the bad one that I made.”

Heck, Jones was second-guessing his biggest personnel decision of the offseason, which seemed to signal a shift to a more financially sound approach by the Cowboys' front office. He felt forced to let release DeMarcus Ware, the franchise's all-time sacks leader, due to the defensive end's high salary and the Cowboys' salary cap concerns.

"Now, I'm going to throw this one at you: What if you had Ware out here with the way he's playing now with the effort of this team?” Jones said, well aware that Ware has 10 sacks for the Denver Broncos, twice as many as any Dallas pass-rusher. "We didn't cost ourselves a Super Bowl because we don't have him out there, did we? A major pressure player out here right now would make you want to give a quarter of the stadium for.”

That decision can certainly be debated.

The Cowboys' general manager is far from perfect. But Jones isn't a punchline at this point, not with those playoff tickets actually of use.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,197
The Ware decision was right one for the team at the time, but forcing DeMarcus Lawrence out of the draft to replace Ware has made it look worse since.

Had Jones kept Ware I'm sure Dallas would not have felt so insanely desperate and passed on the Lawrence trade. They probably would have taken Kony Ealy and Trai Turner. Ealy has the size, became a solid contributor vs the run early on and started getting sacks, though just 3 and is in the rotation at DE. Still he's only going to get better and gives them options for the future. Turner is the Panthers' starting RG, and just imagine how deep and tough this OL would be for the next five years with him pressing Leary.

Instead we have no Ware and Lawrence, who has zero sacks and has barely played, and are trusting Bernadeau as our top interior backup.

Taken together, yeah I wish we had kept Ware.
 

Texas Ace

Teh Acester
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,455
He can't get credit for the Martin pick when he was dead set on taking Manziel, and was pissed off that he was talked out of it.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,197
He can't get credit for the Martin pick when he was dead set on taking Manziel, and was pissed off that he was talked out of it.
I might have flown to Dallas and pole-axed him had he taken that no-talent, overhyped little shit.

My friends were watching my facebook posts during the draft and got worried about me as Manziel fell. He is not a pro prospect. I don't understand how NFL scouts let themselves get fooled this way.
 

L.T. Fan

I'm Easy If You Are
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
21,698
The Ware decision was right one for the team at the time, but forcing DeMarcus Lawrence out of the draft to replace Ware has made it look worse since.

Had Jones kept Ware I'm sure Dallas would not have felt so insanely desperate and passed on the Lawrence trade. They probably would have taken Kony Ealy and Trai Turner. Ealy has the size, became a solid contributor vs the run early on and started getting sacks, though just 3 and is in the rotation at DE. Still he's only going to get better and gives them options for the future. Turner is the Panthers' starting RG, and just imagine how deep and tough this OL would be for the next five years with him pressing Leary.

Instead we have no Ware and Lawrence, who has zero sacks and has barely played, and are trusting Bernadeau as our top interior backup.

Taken together, yeah I wish we had kept Ware.
It wasn't financially responsible to keep Ware.
 

Jiggyfly

Banned
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
9,220
The Ware decision was right one for the team at the time, but forcing DeMarcus Lawrence out of the draft to replace Ware has made it look worse since.

Had Jones kept Ware I'm sure Dallas would not have felt so insanely desperate and passed on the Lawrence trade. They probably would have taken Kony Ealy and Trai Turner. Ealy has the size, became a solid contributor vs the run early on and started getting sacks, though just 3 and is in the rotation at DE. Still he's only going to get better and gives them options for the future. Turner is the Panthers' starting RG, and just imagine how deep and tough this OL would be for the next five years with him pressing Leary.

Instead we have no Ware and Lawrence, who has zero sacks and has barely played, and are trusting Bernadeau as our top interior backup.

Taken together, yeah I wish we had kept Ware.
What do you mean Lawrence has barely Played?

Do you think if Lawrence was playing with the guys Ealy has it would make a difference?
 

Cowboysrock55

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
52,625
He can't get credit for the Martin pick when he was dead set on taking Manziel, and was pissed off that he was talked out of it.
Sure he can. Ultimately Jerry made the final decision on who to draft. It's the job of the GM to listen to his scouts and put the right scouts in place. Jerry did exactly that.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,197
What do you mean Lawrence has barely Played?

Do you think if Lawrence was playing with the guys Ealy has it would make a difference?
Ealy didn't start over Carolina's incumbents, but has had 3 sacks in relief and has been solid vs. the run. He was rated as one of the best preseason run defenders. His history at Mizz was to improve every year, and I think he's steadily improving in the pros as well. He's got the size for sure.

That doesn't even begin to cover what Trai Turner, the guard we lost, has done.

Lawrence broke his foot practicing against a better and more powerful player and missed 8 games as a result. He had every opportunity to start, and frankly I liked what I saw from Anthony Spencer coming off microfracture surgery yesterday better than what I saw (or didn't see) from Lawrence.

Demarcus needs to improve his stamina, size, strength, and speed a great deal next year. That BS about him "reinventing" his body was a load of crap. He has been completely invisible.
 

Jiggyfly

Banned
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
9,220
Ealy didn't start over Carolina's incumbents, but has had 3 sacks in relief and has been solid vs. the run. He was rated as one of the best preseason run defenders. His history at Mizz was to improve every year, and I think he's steadily improving in the pros as well. He's got the size for sure.

That doesn't even begin to cover what Trai Turner, the guard we lost, has done.

Lawrence broke his foot practicing against a better and more powerful player and missed 8 games as a result. He had every opportunity to start, and frankly I liked what I saw from Anthony Spencer coming off microfracture surgery yesterday better than what I saw (or didn't see) from Lawrence.

Demarcus needs to improve his stamina, size, strength, and speed a great deal next year. That BS about him "reinventing" his body was a load of crap. He has been completely invisible.
Incumbents?

He was on the bench behind a undrafted free agent when Hardy got suspended.:lol
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,197
Incumbents?

He was on the bench behind a undrafted free agent when Hardy got suspended.:lol
He wasn't on IR. Demarcus hasn't come close to threatening Mincey or Selvie and now apparently Anthony Spencer.

Niether are ready to start, though Ealy is closer, and the comparison isn't even valid without adding in the loss of Turner.

My initial point was Ware + Ealy + Turner >>> Lawrence. Can that be disputed at this point?
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,515
My initial point was Ware + Ealy + Turner >>> Lawrence. Can that be disputed at this point?
Jeez.

That is sobering.

I haven't followed Ealy much but if he turns into an equal player to Lawrence in the long run (that is to say, quality starting DE but not elite pass rusher), that is gonna sting.

We could have our starting OL set with Turner and moving Martin out to RT, and Ware still here teaming up with Ealy to form a nice starting tandem. We might be in much better shape defensively.
 

Jiggyfly

Banned
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
9,220
He wasn't on IR. Demarcus hasn't come close to threatening Mincey or Selvie and now apparently Anthony Spencer.

Niether are ready to start, though Ealy is closer, and the comparison isn't even valid without adding in the loss of Turner.

My initial point was Ware + Ealy + Turner >>> Lawrence. Can that be disputed at this point?
Threatening?

He is in the rotation and when healthy has been getting about the same number of snaps.

What the hell does Ware have to do with anything in this discussion.

Look I have no idea if Lawrence is going to do anything, but you continuing to write him off for Ealy is comical especially considering you have not taken the time to actually watch him play, he has done some good things.
 

data

Forbes #1
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
50,298
Ware just cant avoid being the topic of discussion. Bookend to bookend of his career here. it first started with 'merriman vs ware'
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,197
Jeez.

That is sobering.

I haven't followed Ealy much but if he turns into an equal player to Lawrence in the long run (that is to say, quality starting DE but not elite pass rusher), that is gonna sting.

We could have our starting OL set with Turner and moving Martin out to RT, and Ware still here teaming up with Ealy to form a nice starting tandem. We might be in much better shape defensively.
It's hindsight of course. I have nothing against Lawrence personally, I just don't think he is what the Cowboys were hoping he was and I certainly don't think he is worth both Ealy and Turner.

I was in favor of cutting Ware, BTW. I just didn't think Dallas would try to milk a pass rusher out of the draft when there wasn't one to be had. Ealy will be a fine 3-technique one day. Lawrence has boom or bust written all over him.
 
Top Bottom