Archer: 5 Wonders - More on Tony Romo sitting

Cotton

One-armed Knife Sharpener
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
120,419
5 Wonders: More on Tony Romo sitting

August, 6, 2013

By Todd Archer | ESPNDallas.com


OXNARD, Calif. – One preseason game is in the books and four remain, but there are plenty of things to wonder about.

So on it is to our third training camp installment of Five Wonders:

** On the grand schemes of things Tony Romo not playing a series against Miami is not that big of a deal. With issues on the offensive line and Romo’s lack of offseason work because of the back surgery, the team thought it was wiser to sit the quarterback against the Dolphins. Well, I wonder what they were thinking about in 2010 and ’11 when they didn’t sit Romo with offensive line issues when he had to play more. In 2010 at San Diego,Robert Brewster had to play right tackle with Marc Colombo and Alex Barron hurt, but Romo played four series. In 2011, the Cowboys made the decision to part ways with center Andre Gurode before they played at Minnesota and had undrafted rookie Kevin Kowalski start with Phil Costa out. It was the first time Romo took a snap from Kowalski all summer. And Kowalski was the third rookie to start that night with Bill Nagy and Tyron Smith. There was no worry that night either. Again, it’s not a huge deal that Romo didn’t play against Miami, but it’s just notable given what happened in recent history.

** Now that Larry Allen has been inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Charles Haleyfigures to be the next Cowboy to make it. Haley has been a finalist the last few years and the feeling among voters is that the question is “when” not “if” Haley will make it. But I wonder who will be the next Cowboy to take up a lifetime residence in Canton, Ohio. Perhaps Chuck Howley, Lee Roy Jordan, Cliff Harris and Drew Pearson get a look from the Veterans Committee. But what of the more-recent era Cowboys? Darren Woodson should gain consideration but the safety position has never been a popular pick among the voters. Woodson was covering slot receivers before it was fashionable for safeties to do so. He was truly ahead of his time in some ways. I’m not sure there is another 90s Era player that will get a look, but Jerry Jones will be in there one day. Maybe soon too.

** Forever, it seems, the Cowboys have found success stories in undrafted free agents: Romo, Miles Austin, Stephen Bowen and Dan Bailey are among the more recent vintage. But I wonder if there will be one undrafted free agent to make the team this year. Really. The leader would appear to be linebacker Brandon Magee, who could become a big part of the special teams’ units. Even those who haven’t seen Eric Rogers play a snap seem to think he can be Keyshawn Johnson, but the Cal Lutheran product has a lot of work to do in earning a spot. Safety Jeff Heath has been an under-the-radar guy and Jakar Hamilton, who received $10,000 to sign, has yet to make a mark in camp. There is a lot of time to make a push but right now there isn’t a lock yet.

** It’s hard to gauge just how interested the Cowboys are in Brian Waters. They know he is available, but they haven’t really put the full-court press on him just yet. Maybe they wanted to see Ronald Leary in a game before going ahead with it. But if they are going to sign Waters, I wonder if it’s too late. He did not take part in an offseason program last year and did not sign with a team. He was not with a team this offseason either. What kind of shape is he in? If the Cowboys bring Waters in, it’s not for a workout. It’s to sign him. He signed with New England in 2011 a week before the season started and ended up in the Pro Bowl. But in players’ years, that could be a lifetime ago.

** Let’s close with a game involving a 53-man roster projection. I wonder if the final spot or two comes down to a seventh linebacker, fourth running back, a 10th offensive linemen, a sixth wide receiver or a ninth defensive lineman? If that’s the case, then Magee, Phillip Tanner, Darrion Weems, Anthony Armstrong, Tim Benford, Eric Rogers or a George Selvieare fighting for one or two spots right now. Right now, I’m not sure the ninth or 10th offensive lineman is on the roster. Armstrong has had a really good camp and his speed separates him from some others. Selvie could be insurance for Anthony Spencer being banged up and helped himself with Sunday’s two-sack effort. Tanner also helped his cause. Based on what Tanner, Selvie and Armstrong did against Miami, it looks like the Cowboys will have a decision to make as opposed to trying to find players to keep.
 

UncleMilti

This seemed like a good idea at the time.
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
18,007
** On the grand schemes of things Tony Romo not playing a series against Miami is not that big of a deal. With issues on the offensive line and Romo’s lack of offseason work because of the back surgery, the team thought it was wiser to sit the quarterback against the Dolphins. Well, I wonder what they were thinking about in 2010 and ’11 when they didn’t sit Romo with offensive line issues when he had to play more. In 2010 at San Diego,Robert Brewster had to play right tackle with Marc Colombo and Alex Barron hurt, but Romo played four series. In 2011, the Cowboys made the decision to part ways with center Andre Gurode before they played at Minnesota and had undrafted rookie Kevin Kowalski start with Phil Costa out. It was the first time Romo took a snap from Kowalski all summer. And Kowalski was the third rookie to start that night with Bill Nagy and Tyron Smith. There was no worry that night either. Again, it’s not a huge deal that Romo didn’t play against Miami, but it’s just notable given what happened in recent history.
Is Archer a fucking retard?

After the injuries this team had last season, and the freak injuries already this preseason I don't blame Jones or Garrett for being overly cautious.
 

Genghis Khan

The worst version of myself
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
38,045
Plus, when there is a 5th preseason game, that changes how you approach the game. Almost none of the starters played but we're supposed to read something into Romo sitting? Dumb.
 

Cotton

One-armed Knife Sharpener
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
120,419
Plus, when there is a 5th preseason game, that changes how you approach the game. Almost none of the starters played but we're supposed to read something into Romo sitting? Dumb.
Hell, Jerry already said that the only reason they took the HOF game was to get the extra week of practice.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,245
Stepnoski belongs in. He's on the all-decade team.
Hall of Very Good.

IMO the HOF should be reserved for truly special players and I never thought that of Stepnoski.

For example, Emmitt's most dominant playoff rushing performance was behind Frank Cornish. The true difference-makers up front were Big E and later Larry Allen. The Cowboys OL was borderline bad for the first two of Stepnoski's seasons, and then suddenly Big E made it dominant. His presence caused a ripple effect as he never needed help from the TE or RG, freeing Novacek and Gesek/Gogan. When Big E went down, a young Larry was in place to pick up the slack, but it was a huge loss. For some gay reason RTs don't make All-Decade teams because the position is "Tackle" and only LT's are considered. But it took Erik Williams to take down Reggie White and take the running game to the next level.

You just can't write the history of the NFL without mentioning Drew Pearson. He was an all-decade team member, ROHer, and made multiple clutch playoff catches for two different QB's, including "Hail Mary".

Everyone was on pins and needles when Too Tall Jones returned to the Cowboys from boxing. Boxing actually made him better and he became All-Pro three years in a row after returning. I don't know of any other Cowboy DE who did that. Jones changed the game the moment he got on the field, and lord knows how many interceptions on the left side of the defense he helped contribute to. The man played 15 dominant seasons, and who knows how many sacks he'd have had if Landry hadn't forced that Flex crap on first and second down or if the NFL kept the actual statistics.

Then there's Harvey Martin, who was as good a pass rusher as Jones was an all-around DE. Complete beast and of course, Superbowl co-MVP.

I'd put Darren Woodson ahead of everyone on the 1990's All-Decade team listed as safety. I thought Woodson was better than Atwater (hitter only), Butler, Lake, and Ronnie Lott (who was ancient). That was the biggest slight I've seen, and there's just no justification for it. He's a lock for the ROH, IMO, and should be at least considered for the HOF.
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,585
Well, Stepnoski made the All-Decade team and continued to make Pro Bowls after he left Dallas. I think he belongs.
 

Genghis Khan

The worst version of myself
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
38,045
I agree. If you are good enough to be the best at your position for an entire decade, you should be essentially presumed in unless there is a compelling reason to keep you out.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,245
Well, Stepnoski made the All-Decade team and continued to make Pro Bowls after he left Dallas. I think he belongs.
A legit opinion no doubt. I liked him obviously, but believe he's clearly behind the players I mentioned.
 

junk

Not So New Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
580
An argument could be made for Step but I'd put Woodson in before him
 

Carl

RIP Brother
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
1,372
Woodson is borderline. Sentimentality would mean he gets my vote; but I don't think he would get enough votes elsewhere. Stepnoski is not HOF material.
 

Texas Ace

Teh Acester
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,508
Woodson belongs.

He was the best safety of the 90's and was much more well rounded than either Butler or Lynch.

Butler wasn't the tackler or run stopper that Woodson was and Lynch wasn't half the cover guy.

Woodson was a better version of Brian Dawkins, and I'm guessing he'll get more of a nod which is a shame.
 

boozeman

28 Years And Counting...
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
123,342
I know it sounds like blasphemy, but I think Dawkins is at least on a par with Woody, if not better. Jim Johnson basically built that D around him and it was pretty decent.

Frick Leroy Butler and Lynch.
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,585
I know it sounds like blasphemy, but I think Dawkins is at least on a par with Woody, if not better. Jim Johnson basically built that D around him and it was pretty decent.

Frick Leroy Butler and Lynch.
No, that's legit. I think I would say that Dawkins is better.
 

Genghis Khan

The worst version of myself
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
38,045
Blasphemy indeed. Dawkins was nowhere near Woodson in coverage.
 

ravidubey

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
20,245
I know it sounds like blasphemy, but I think Dawkins is at least on a par with Woody, if not better. Jim Johnson basically built that D around him and it was pretty decent.

Frick Leroy Butler and Lynch.
Dawkins was an animal, and clearly as good or better than Woody. Dawkins could blitz better than any safety I've seen and was a ballhawk too. Has any safety ever had more forced fumbles than Dawkins? And as you said, Johnson built his defense around Dawkins' capabilities.

And Butler and Lynch can go fuck themselves. Butler had his day, but a great season in 1996 doesn't make you the best safety in the league.
 

boozeman

28 Years And Counting...
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
123,342
Blasphemy indeed. Dawkins was nowhere near Woodson in coverage.
Your hatred of all things Philly is clouding your judgment.

And Woodson was a smidge overrated in coverage...the last two of three years of his career they kept putting him in the slot and he'd get burned. He also rarely made the kind of plays that Dawkins did. Then again, I think he was utilized wrong in Campo/Zimmer D's.
 

Clay_Allison

Old Bastard
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
5,488
Well, Stepnoski made the All-Decade team and continued to make Pro Bowls after he left Dallas. I think he belongs.
The line was better with Donaldson healthy in 1995 than it ever was with Stepnoski.

Step wasn't anchoring a poor line in Tennessee either, Bruce Matthews, Brad Hopkins, Jon Runyan? Not bad guys to play alongside.

Stepnoski was an undersized guy with good athleticism and brains that was lucky to play on powerhouse lines that could cover his lack of physical strength and size.
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,585
The line was better with Donaldson healthy in 1995 than it ever was with Stepnoski.

Step wasn't anchoring a poor line in Tennessee either, Bruce Matthews, Brad Hopkins, Jon Runyan? Not bad guys to play alongside.

Stepnoski was an undersized guy with good athleticism and brains that was lucky to play on powerhouse lines that could cover his lack of physical strength and size.
You've said that before and I don't particularly agree.

That being said Donaldson was a legit Pro Bowler in his own right, he just didn't make any All-Decade teams.
 
Top Bottom