Watkins - Cowboys mailbag: Is it time to release Nate Livings?

boozeman

28 Years And Counting...
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
123,392
Cowboys mailbag: Is it time to release Nate Livings?

August, 4, 2013


By Calvin Watkins | ESPNDallas.com


OXNARD, Calif. -- This week's mailbag takes us to the safety position where one fans wants to know about Matt Johnson's progress and came and another asks about Barry Church's root canal. The best question of the bunch surrounds left guard Nate Livings and whether or not the Cowboys should send him packing. It's early in training camp and he's recovering from knee surgery, so he's going to be around a while.

Here's the mailbag.

Q: Calvin, I'm high on Matt Johnson. Do you believe as I do and hope that he'll start for us at some point this season? Nebe Ermyas (Silver Spring, Md.)

A: We'll know plenty about Johnson on Sunday night in the Hall of Fame game when the Cowboys take on the Miami Dolphins. Johnson is currently getting second-team snaps at safety. In team drills we've seen Johnson get one interception, where he returned it for a score. Johnson as drafted in 2012 because of his ability to make plays on the ball. The Cowboys project him to be a starter in the future, but he's not better than veteran Will Allen or the other starter, Barry Church. J.J. Wilcox has played well in two weeks of training camp practices and we've like what Danny McCray has done with the third team. Johnson has had some moments, but Sunday night he gets his chance to show the coaches what he can do in a game after missing last season with a hamstring injury.

Q: What do you think about Bill Callahan calling the plays instead of Jason Garrett and do you think he's on the hot seat? (Kelly Hoskins, Henderson, Nev.)

A: I'm not sure if Callahan can improve the passing attack because Garrett did a pretty good job there. Garrett has said he's making a renewed commitment to the running game and this is where Callahan fits. He'll make sure the Cowboys establish the run attack early in the game, something Garrett didn't do enough of last season. New running backs coach Gary Brown is teaching new techniques to the the player making sure they take one cut and get garbage yards and stop looking for big gains. Garrett has preached it's a collaborative effort when it comes to the offense and with Callahan's playcalling and the teachings of Brown, I think the run game will improve in 2013.

Q: Why don't the Cowboys just cut Nate Livings? He is always hurt and from the sounds of camp so far he has sucked. What will be the salary cap ramifications if he is cut this year? Karl Fuller (Douglasville, Ga.)

A: Livings is out for possibly a month after undergoing knee surgery last week. The Cowboys take a $1.7 million cap hit if Livings is released, which I doubt the team wants to do at this stage. The interesting thing about releasing a player is finding his replacment. The Cowboys are high on Ronald Leary to take over at left guard, but he's inexperienced and these five preseason games are a good test for him. Livings will remain with the team in 2013, but after that it's a question.

Q: Based on what you've seen so far, how much better or worse is the offensive line this year over last? Mark Pachankis (Bossier City, La.)

A: The offensive line had its troubles last season with injuries, three different starting centers, an ineffective play. The first-round selection of center Travis Frederick should improve things in the interior and another year of seasoning from Tyron Smith of the left side should give Cowboys' fans hope. Doug Free has performed well in training camp at right tackle, but the guard spots are where the questions arise. It's too early for answers on how the line will do in 2013, but after two weeks of practices things have been inconsistent.

Q: What's going on with Barry Church? Is he back from the root canal? And how does he look? (Nate from New Jersey)

A: Church is the deep safety in Monte Kiffin's defense and he's moved around well from his torn Achilles. I know you asked is he back since his root canal -- he is -- but that was just a minor thing in comparison to what he returned from. Secondary coach Jerome Henderson said Church is playing with confidence and is comfortable at the safety position. Allen has been a positive influence on Church and the two could make a pretty good duo when the season starts.
 

Texas Ace

Teh Acester
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,513
Q: Calvin, I'm high on Matt Johnson.
Why? Why are so many people "high" on this guy?

He hasn't played a single down of pro football and he can't go more than a few days without getting hurt. He hasn't shown anyone a single thing because he's never been on the field long enough to do so. And did I mention that he's a 4th rounder from a nobody school?

So given all of this, why on earth do so many people insist on believing that this guy has real potential? What is this foolishness based on?

I have absolutely no hopes of him becoming anything and expect him to be out of football completely in 2014. If he made so much as a tackle in a regular season game for us, that would be a pleasant surprise because it would be way more of a contribution than I'm expecting out of him.
 

Cowboysrock55

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
53,272
Why? Why are so many people "high" on this guy?

He hasn't played a single down of pro football and he can't go more than a few days without getting hurt. He hasn't shown anyone a single thing because he's never been on the field long enough to do so. And did I mention that he's a 4th rounder from a nobody school?

So given all of this, why on earth do so many people insist on believing that this guy has real potential? What is this foolishness based on?

I have absolutely no hopes of him becoming anything and expect him to be out of football completely in 2014. If he made so much as a tackle in a regular season game for us, that would be a pleasant surprise because it would be way more of a contribution than I'm expecting out of him.
From everything I have read so far JJ Wilcox has been playing as well as any safety on our roster. Not sure if that is a good thing or a sad thing.
 

Texas Ace

Teh Acester
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
23,513
He's the new great white hope.
If the guy came from a big school, or at least a competitive conference, then MAYBE I'd hold out some hope for him. But he didn't come from either one of those situations, and as a matter of fact, he wasn't even this all world safety in the WGAS conference he played in.

There is zero pedigree with this guy and that's why I don't understand at all why anyone uses the terms "potential" or "hope" with him.
 

boozeman

28 Years And Counting...
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
123,392
So given all of this, why on earth do so many people insist on believing that this guy has real potential? What is this foolishness based on?
Grainy YouTube vids with Eastern Washington playing Podunk Tech. Duh.
 

1bigfan13

Your favorite player's favorite player
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
27,201
Why? Why are so many people "high" on this guy?

He hasn't played a single down of pro football and he can't go more than a few days without getting hurt. He hasn't shown anyone a single thing because he's never been on the field long enough to do so. And did I mention that he's a 4th rounder from a nobody school?

So given all of this, why on earth do so many people insist on believing that this guy has real potential? What is this foolishness based on?

I have absolutely no hopes of him becoming anything and expect him to be out of football completely in 2014. If he made so much as a tackle in a regular season game for us, that would be a pleasant surprise because it would be way more of a contribution than I'm expecting out of him.
It's just because he's a Cowboy. There are a handful of idiots at the Zone who are sold on Johnson as well.

All because he wears the star. If he were a Redskin they'd be lol'ing the guy.
 

Bob Roberts

Professor StinkFinger
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
3,023
If the guy came from a big school, or at least a competitive conference, then MAYBE I'd hold out some hope for him. But he didn't come from either one of those situations, and as a matter of fact, he wasn't even this all world safety in the WGAS conference he played in.

There is zero pedigree with this guy and that's why I don't understand at all why anyone uses the terms "potential" or "hope" with him.
Come on, he's clearly John Lynch 2.0
 
Top Bottom