Cowlishaw: Josh Brent deserves another chance, just not with the Cowboys
Tim Cowlishaw
wtcowlishaw@dallasnews.com
Published: 02 September 2014 09:08 PM
Updated: 03 September 2014 01:20 AM
A cynic would suggest the best way to handle what is likely to be perceived as bad news is with a pre-emptive strike, a “good news” story to distract the critics. Let’s hope the Cowboys’ plans to sign Michael Sam to their practice squad represent more than just a marvelous misdirection called by Jerry Jones.
It was not quite two hours after the Sam news broke Tuesday afternoon that the NFL’s 10-week suspension of Josh Brent was announced in a news release. That’s right. I can’t tell you if Sam, the openly gay defensive end cut Friday by the St. Louis Rams, will ever play for the Cowboys. He might suit up this season or he could be released in two weeks.
But barring any setbacks or a failure to meet the terms of his agreement with the NFL, Brent will be back at defensive tackle for the Cowboys in New York on Nov. 23 when the Cowboys meet the Giants.
That’s just shy of two years since he last played for Dallas. Just shy of two years since, as the evidence detailed, he drove his Mercedes 110 miles per hour with a blood alcohol level of .18 — more than twice the legal limit — and killed teammate and best friend Jerry Brown Jr.
I have said before that while I think Brent has the right to play — it’s hard to call it a “second chance” since he was convicted of DUI while at the University of Illinois — I think that opportunity should come elsewhere. A fresh start for all concerned, including Cowboys fans, would be best.
Some of you will welcome him back because this team has such a porous defense. Many of you will hate his return and see it as a continuation of the declining values of the Cowboys or the NFL.
For those in the second group, let me offer two words: Craig MacTavish.
If you were late arriving to the NHL — say, perhaps when the North Stars moved here from Minnesota in 1993 — you know MacTavish as a winner of Stanley Cups, the last man to play without a helmet, a coach who made a shocking run to Game 7 of the Cup Final in 2006 with Edmonton. He’s the Oilers’ GM today.
He’s also a man who was convicted of vehicular manslaughter as a young player with the Boston Bruins in 1984. Driving drunk, he killed a young woman, pled guilty and spent a year in jail.
He actually switched teams while incarcerated and went on to the successful career I have mentioned. Nothing can ever change what happened, but he was allowed to return to the game he loved after doing time. He turned his life around.
Isn’t Brent deserving of the same opportunity?
We know nothing is going to change where his young teammate is concerned. We also know Brown’s mother has consistently expressed hope that the Cowboys will welcome Brent back to the team.
It’s not a feel-good story or anything of the sort. But is it fair? Maybe.
Brent was sentenced and served his time. If you believe he deserved more than six months, that's more of an issue you have with America’s judicial system than America’s Team.
The 10-year probation remains in play. Brent cannot afford the slightest of slip-ups without risking a lengthy and quite obviously career-ending return to jail.
I believe everyone would be better served if his return to the NFL came with an AFC team. A new set of teammates, new fans, new surroundings. I know there are those that will say the Cowboys know him best and can help him fight his demons.
Well, he lost that battle the last time he was on their roster. And a young man lost his life.
The NFL’s 10-game suspension is punitive enough, given the time served and the money Brent already has lost. Yes, it’s silly to suspend Cleveland wide receiver Josh Gordon for 16 games for repeated failures of marijuana tests, but that’s a collectively bargained issue that needs to be changed.
Brent’s agent, Peter Schaffer, won’t be doing his client any favors in the court of public opinion if he appeals this suspension as indicated he will.
The football landscape is different since we last saw Brent play. The Cowboys have changed their defense once and coordinators twice. How Brent can help this team as a 4-3 tackle remains to be determined.
You can’t change the past. But, for all concerned, Brent’s future would be better explored if it followed the path taken by the NHL and MacTavish — in another city with another team.
Josh Brent reinstatement
Josh Brent has been conditionally reinstated as an NFL player with the Cowboys but will not be eligible to play until at least Week 11, the Cowboys’ bye week. If he is fully reinstated, he would have missed a total of 30 regular-season games since the 2012 incident that led to his intoxication manslaughter conviction. Brent’s reinstatement is based on the following conditions:
— Suspension without pay for the first 10 weeks of the 2014 regular season.
— During the first six weeks, he is not permitted to visit the club facility or participate in any team activities except to meet with his clinician or the club’s player engagement director.
— Beginning Week 7, he will be permitted to attend team meetings and do individual workouts and conditioning. He will not be permitted to practice, travel with the team or attend games.
— Beginning Week 9, he will be permitted to engage in all team activities but he may not travel with the team or participate in games.
— He must fully comply with any evaluation, treatment or counseling required by medical or other professionals assigned to him.
— He must fully comply with the requirements set forth by the courts regarding his probation, testing and monitoring.
— He must have no further adverse involvement with law enforcement.
— Any prohibited alcohol-related conduct will likely result in an immediate suspension and potential banishment from the NFL.
— Brent may appeal this decision within five days