Week 14 Game Day Chatter | Eagles @ Cowboys | 12-09-2018

jsmith6919

Honored Member - RIP
Joined
Aug 26, 2013
Messages
28,407
 

Simpleton

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
17,413
I’m predicting the Packers get #6 seed by winning out to finish 8-7-1. I think I prefer to stay #4 seed and face Seattle at home.
Minnesota has the tiebreaker if they go 2-1, can't see them losing to Miami or Detroit even with how shit they were tonight.
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,488
I do love how you can be dead wrong but it's someone else's fault. I was basing it off ESPN.com which lists Dak at 8 fumbles on the season. They listed Romo's as 8 as well. The point remains Romo had more of a fumbling problem in the first 3 years of his career and both guys third years are pretty similar in terms of fumbles. Even though you claim your memory tells you something different.
I'm not "dead wrong." Prescott does not have 8 fumbles this year. He has 12. Yes, this misunderstanding is, in fact, your fault, if you meant to say fumbles lost but did not, and also if you relied on incorrect ESPN numbers.

My memory, same as everyone here who isn't a Dak apologist such as yourself, remembers without question that Romo was the superior QB to Dak.

Post some more QB rating stats to try to convince us otherwise, though.
 
Last edited:

lostxn

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
7,874
I'm not "dead wrong." Prescott does not have 8 fumbles this year. He has 12. Yes, this misunderstanding is, in fact, your fault, if you meant to say fumbles lost but did not, and also if you relied on incorrect ESPN numbers.
Damn you are a little bitch sometimes. I loved Romo as much as anyone, but perhaps comparing a 10 year starter to a 3 year one is a little unfair. Romo was a turnover machine in his first 3 years. Here's the proof (look at picks and fumbles, fumbles are nearly identical and Romo played 6 fewer games). Now stfu.

Dak
YearGGSCmpAttPctYdsAvgLngTDIntRtgAttYdsAvgLngTDFumLost
2016161631145967.83,667883234104.9572824.918694
2017161630849062.83,3246.881221386.6573576.321643
2018131328541868.23,1317.59017796.8673034.5285126
Career45459041,36766.110,1227.490622495.81819425.228172513

Romo
YearGGSCmpAttPctYdsAvgTDIntRtgAttYdsAvgTDFumLost
2006161022033765.3 2,9038.6191395.1341023.0093
2007161633552064.4 4,2118.1361997.4311294.22102
2008131327645061.3 3,4487.7261491.428411.50137
3-Yr4539831130763.6 10,5628.1814694.7932722.923212
 
  • Props
Reactions: Rev

L.T. Fan

I'm Easy If You Are
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
21,689
You gonna take this, L.T. Fan ?
Some people just don’t understand that a Super Bowl thropy is a team award. Ask Trent Dilfer if he won the Super Bowl despite the team who was around him. The use of Super Bowls as a Quarter Back yard stick is a silly premise. That would make Dan Marino a bum along with Romo.
 

Cowboysrock55

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
52,453
I'm not "dead wrong." Prescott does not have 8 fumbles this year. He has 12. Yes, this misunderstanding is, in fact, your fault, if you meant to say fumbles lost but did not, and also if you relied on incorrect ESPN numbers.

My memory, same as everyone here who isn't a Dak apologist such as yourself, remembers without question that Romo was the superior QB to Dak.

Post some more QB rating stats to try to convince us otherwise, though.
You forgot to mention Romo fumbled more in a season before. Even though you swore otherwise.
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,488
Damn you are a little bitch sometimes. I loved Romo as much as anyone, but perhaps comparing a 10 year starter to a 3 year one is a little unfair. Romo was a turnover machine in his first 3 years. Here's the proof (look at picks and fumbles, fumbles are nearly identical and Romo played 6 fewer games). Now stfu.

Dak
YearGGSCmpAttPctYdsAvgLngTDIntRtgAttYdsAvgLngTDFumLost
2016161631145967.83,667883234104.9572824.918694
2017161630849062.83,3246.881221386.6573576.321643
2018131328541868.23,1317.59017796.8673034.5285126
Career45459041,36766.110,1227.490622495.81819425.228172513

Romo
YearGGSCmpAttPctYdsAvgTDIntRtgAttYdsAvgTDFumLost
2006161022033765.3 2,9038.6191395.1341023.0093
2007161633552064.4 4,2118.1361997.4311294.22102
2008131327645061.3 3,4487.7261491.428411.50137
3-Yr4539831130763.6 10,5628.1814694.7932722.923212
Cowboysrock said Romo had 8 fumbles. I assumed that was true as stated; however, I knew that Prescott had 12 cause I had looked earlier that day at his stats. When I made the statement “Dak and Romo’s fumbles are not comparable,” it was because I was relying on C-rock’s incorrect statement that Romo and Prescott each had 8 fumbles. I knew Prescott had 12 fumbles, and 12 through 13 games is not comparable to 8 in 16 games. That would be a true statement.

the source of this confusion is that C-rock meant Fumbles LOST. Yes, obviously those numbers are comparable.

i stand by my statement, which is obviously my original intent, that as QBs overall, they are not at all comparable at this point in their careers. Romo is significantly better.
 

Rev

Good, bad, I'm the guy with the gun
Staff member
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
19,327
Damn you are a little bitch sometimes. I loved Romo as much as anyone, but perhaps comparing a 10 year starter to a 3 year one is a little unfair. Romo was a turnover machine in his first 3 years. Here's the proof (look at picks and fumbles, fumbles are nearly identical and Romo played 6 fewer games). Now stfu.

Dak
YearGGSCmpAttPctYdsAvgLngTDIntRtgAttYdsAvgLngTDFumLost
2016161631145967.83,667883234104.9572824.918694
2017161630849062.83,3246.881221386.6573576.321643
2018131328541868.23,1317.59017796.8673034.5285126
Career45459041,36766.110,1227.490622495.81819425.228172513

Romo
YearGGSCmpAttPctYdsAvgTDIntRtgAttYdsAvgTDFumLost
2006161022033765.3 2,9038.6191395.1341023.0093
2007161633552064.4 4,2118.1361997.4311294.22102
2008131327645061.3 3,4487.7261491.428411.50137
3-Yr4539831130763.6 10,5628.1814694.7932722.923212
:flairphilly
 

Smitty

DCC 4Life
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
22,488
Cowboyrsrock: "Romo and Dak are similar in that they each had 8 fumbles their third year."

Me: "I know for a fact Dak has 12 fumbles. 12 is not 8, 12 is way more than 8. Also Dak has 3 more games to play. Also, Romo is superior to Dak as a QB in just about every other way, and most people realize that."

Cowboysrock: "HoooO! Jokes on you! Romo actually had 13 fumbles and 8 fumbles lost! I said fumbles, but I actually meant fumbles lost! Sucker! Get your facts straight!"

Me: "Uh, ok. Well, you cited the wrong stats. But sure, 13 is close to 12, yes, so in that sense they are similar. However Dak still has 3 games to play and Romo is still better in just about every other regard."

Cowboysrock: "Nu-uh! You swore Dak had more fumbles."

Me: "No. I said Dak did not have 8, I said he had 12. I also said 12 is more than 8, which is true. You incorrectly reported that Romo had 8 fumbles (like you also reported incorrectly that Dak had 8 fumbles). Obviously I would agree that 13 FUMBLES (not fumbles lost) is similar to 12 fumbles (not fumbles lost).

Rev: ~flair gif~
 
  • Props
Reactions: Rev

data

Forbes #1
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
50,293
A lot of vitriol for this QB debate over another bunch of losers.

Trivia: What happened more — Joe Montana turnovers in The Catch game or combined playoff wins amongst Quincy, Hutchinson, Romo and Dak?
 
Top Bottom