MacMahon: Ridiculously premature 53-man roster projection

Ridiculously premature 53-man roster projection

May, 1, 2013


By Tim MacMahon | ESPNDallas.com


The draft is done. Free agency is dragging to the finish line. That means it's about time for the first ridiculously premature 53-man roster projection of the year, an exercise we'll repeat on a weekly basis once training camp begins.

QUARTERBACKS (2)
Tony Romo
Kyle Orton

At some point, the Cowboys need to invest a draft pick in a developmental quarterback again. Maybe next year. For now, carrying only two QBs saves a roster spot for somewhere else.

RUNNING BACKS (4)
DeMarco Murray
Joseph Randle
Lance Dunbar
Phillip Tanner

Tanner needs to impress new special teams coordinator Rich Bisaccia in the preseason. He also needs to beat out undrafted free agent Kendial Lawrence, a Rockwall product via Missouri. No fullback? Lawrence Vickers was a disappointment last season and is coming off of back surgery, and the Cowboys can phase out that position with their renewed emphasis on multiple-tight end sets.

WIDE RECEIVERS (5)
Dez Bryant
Miles Austin
Terrance Williams
Dwayne Harris
Cole Beasley

There’s a lot of young talent here along with Austin, who might not be worth his $54 million deal but is at least a very good No. 2 receiver if he can stay healthy. Harris and Beasley are good enough in the slot to give Austin occasional breaks. The issue with Beasley: How can he help you on special teams with Harris handling punt returns?

TIGHT ENDS (3)
Jason Witten
Gavin Escobar
James Hanna

This could be one of the best pass-catching tight end corps in the league. The problem: Both of Witten’s backups are adequate at best as blockers. Keeping (or acquiring) a rugged fourth tight end is a distinct possibility.

OFFENSIVE LINEMEN (10)
Tyron Smith
Travis Frederick
Nate Livings
Mackenzy Bernadeau
Doug Free
Jermey Parnell
Phil Costa
Darrion Weems
Kevin Kowalski
Ronald Leary

You don’t want to see Free on here, right? Well, that decision is apparently up to him. The Cowboys have presented him the option of taking a pay cut. They hope he accepts it. If he doesn’t, they’ll make him a post-June 1 cut and sign a right tackle in free agency. The top two candidates are Tyson Clabo and Eric Winston, but the Miami Dolphins are likely to sign one of them soon. And Clabo could be out of the Cowboys’ price range. On another note, can Costa be the short-yardage fullback?

DEFENSIVE LINE (9)
DeMarcus Ware
Anthony Spencer
Jay Ratliff
Jason Hatcher
Sean Lissemore
Tyrone Crawford
Brian Price
Kyle Wilber
Rob Callaway

Jerry Jones declared the defensive line to be a position of strength while ignoring it on draft weekend. That’s a curious decision, considering the age of the starters and the lack of proven depth. The Cowboys need 2012 third-round pick Crawford to prove this season that he’s a starting-caliber player, whether it’s at defensive tackle or the strongside end.


LINEBACKERS (7)
Sean Lee
Bruce Carter
Justin Durant
Alex Albright
Ernie Sims
DeVonte Holloman
Brandon Magee

Lee and Carter are studs if they can stay healthy, but that’s a big if given their injury histories. The Cowboys gave Magee, an undrafted free agent out of Arizona State, more guaranteed money ($70,000) than any seventh-round pick got last year.

CORNERBACKS (5)
Brandon Carr
Morris Claiborne
Orlando Scandrick
B.W. Webb
Sterling Moore

Scandrick probably needs to have a good season to prevent the Cowboys from making a cap casualty next year. If they’re right on fourth-rounder Webb, he can play the slot for about a tenth of Scandrick’s salary. The Cowboys need Claiborne to live up to his billing after a so-so rookie season that fell well short of the sky-high, Jerry-aided hype.

SAFETIES (5)
Barry Church
Matt Johnson
J.J. Wilcox
Will Allen
Danny McCray

Allen and McCray might be the best special teams players on the roster, but their roster spots are far from guaranteed, especially if the young safeties perform well in training camp and the preseason. Allen signed for less guaranteed money than camp cut Brodney Pool did last year, and McCray returned on a one-year deal as a restricted free agent.

SPECIALISTS (3)
Dan Bailey
Chris Jones
L.P. Ladouceur

No reason to make any changes here, as long as Jones is fully healthy coming off of a season-ending knee injury.

It's never premature with this team since Jerry basically decides a lot of who'll start in April.

That looks right to me with the exception of maybe adding Vickers back in at the expense of Tanner or Dunbar, swapping Danny Coale for Cole Beasley, and maybe changing out an OL or two for different OLs. Possibly Ben Bass for Rob Callaway too.

I stare at this at just laugh.

I guarantee you it will be a lot like this.

Mainly because, ya know, there is just so much competition.

I'd flush a RB, DL, and a S for other positions, especially another TE.

BipolarFan said:

I'd flush a RB, DL, and a S for other positions, especially another TE.

Click to expand...

If you are going to cut FB out of your offense entirely I think you keep an extra TE who specializes in blocking. That or just keep Vickers around, I think he is still a bad ass blocker. Not sure who Darrion Weems is, I don't have a problem carrying the fourth OT but is this guy worth saving a roster spot for? Maybe some undrafted guys will step up but right now I'm not seeing any guys that I'll feel bad when we cut.

What is that Costa at FB crap?

mcnuttz said:

What is that Costa at FB crap?

Click to expand...

He's a beast.

Hell, I'd keep a 3rd qb just on the off-chance he happens to develop. We're not winning shit this year anyway.

Is there one even worth keeping?

Doug Free and Phil Costa....epic fail.

SfielDallas said:

Is there one even worth keeping?

Click to expand...

I would allow (if it were up to me, of course it isn't) a lot more latitude in deciding is what I mean. If they all completely suck ass, then no. But if any of them show anything, might as well keep him and see what happens. Keeping an extra O or D lineman isn't going to make a shit's worth of difference this year. We will suck.

Cujo said:

I would allow (if it were up to me, of course it isn't) a lot more latitude in deciding is what I mean. If they all completely suck ass, then no. But if any of them show anything, might as well keep him and see what happens. Keeping an extra O or D lineman isn't going to make a shit's worth of difference this year. We will suck.

Click to expand...

Unless the O or D lineman is a better prospect to develop than the QB.

Clay_Allison said:

Unless the O or D lineman is a better prospect to develop than the QB.

Click to expand...

Ok, duly noted. But what chance is there of that happening? Especially when we didn't get either in rookie free agents.